Let’s not give our trust away for free
قال أبو الحسن الثالث علیه السلام إذا کان زمان العدل فیه أغلب من الجور فحرام أن تظن بأحد سوءا حتى یعلم ذلک منه و إذا کان زمان الجور فیه أغلب من العدل فلیس لأحد أن یظن بأحد خیرا حتى یبدو ذلک منه.
بحار الأنوار (ط - بیروت)، ج72، ص: 197
The age of justice refers to a time when an infallible Imam governs society. When the Imam of justice rules and people follow him, it is as if society’s heart and brain are functioning properly. Under such conditions, trusting one’s senses is a sign of sound reason, while the members of society are like its limbs and nerves.
An age of oppression, by contrast, is one in which unjust rulers—who are not infallible—govern society. In other words, society has strayed from the path of the Imam’s authority. In such conditions, society’s heart and brain do not function properly; corruption and disease spread through its limbs, and its nerves fail to work as they should. It may even mistake sweetness for bitterness and bitterness for sweetness! Indeed, the people of a society are its cells. A society steeped in sin is a society with cancerous cells, even if it also has healthy ones.
So, in such a society, one must be especially vigilant, investigate and examine carefully; otherwise, one should expect ruin.
Note that the hadith says we should not be hasty in thinking well of someone in such a society. It is not telling us to think badly of people; rather, it tells us not to be quick to presume the best. In other words, we should not give everyone a perfect score from the outset—but neither should we give them zero. We should judge only after testing them and making inquiries.