With greetings and best wishes,
Esteemed Professor Saei,
As you are well aware, scholarly differences among the religious scholars of the seminaries have been a blessing that has continually invigorated the Shi‘i seminaries. Their value is such that, whenever these differences have been absent, we have witnessed a severe decline in scholarly activity. For example, when ijtihad gave way to taqlid after Shaykh al-Ta’ifa, the seminaries remained stagnant until the time of the late Ibn Idris, the Shaykh’s grandson. It was Ibn Idris who brought new perspectives and restored vitality to Shi‘i jurisprudence.
But when these differences turn into excommunication or the unjust slandering of others by those around the great religious figures, the blessing of scholarly disagreement becomes a destructive scourge of futile dispute. The question, then, is this: If God, Blessed and Exalted, were to ask us, “You did not understand the meaning of such-and-such according to the philosophers’ school; you did not learn it from a scholar of that discipline, nor study that field and its prerequisites. Why, then, did you blindly excommunicate and insult them?”—what answer could we give in the presence of the Sacred Truth?