If the doctrine of the Unity of Being is not sound at its root, then for what reason did the Prophet (PBUH) describe self-knowledge as the path to knowing God?
If the Unity of Being (Wahdat al-Wujud) Is Not Correct, Why Did the Prophet (PBUH) Describe Self-Knowledge as the Path to Knowing God?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Self-knowledge in no way justifies the Unity of Being. Attaining the sciences and subtleties of the self leads to knowledge of God's beautiful names, not to knowledge of the divine essence. The hadith in which the Prophet (PBUH) describes self-knowledge as the path to knowing God is among the ambiguous (mutashabihat) traditions and should not be taken to mean the Unity of Being.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterSelf-knowledge in no way justifies the doctrine of the unity of being!
In truth, attaining self-knowledge means discovering the knowledge, subtleties, refinements, wisdom, arts, discernment, beauty and majesty of the human soul. Through this knowledge, one comes to know the All-Knowing, the Subtle, the Wise, the Creator, the Beautiful and the Majestic—that is, one comes to know the Most Beautiful Names of God, not God’s Essence!
In reality, self-knowledge is an intellectual grasp of the self and the soul; it can in no way be equal to the Essence of the Real—God forbid! If it were equivalent, that would mean the Divine Essence could be encompassed—سبحانه و تعالى عما یقولون علوا کبیرا—whereas He is the One who encompasses all things.
Whoever attains knowledge of the self gains an intellectual understanding of himself. This shows that the knower has limits and boundaries, has traversed the full extent of his own existence and reached its end. Without doubt, the Divine Essence is holy and far removed from such descriptions.
The words of the Infallibles علیهم السلام likewise include both definitive and ambiguous passages. The ambiguous must be interpreted in light of the definitive. This hadith, too, is among the ambiguous narrations.
The human being is a sign of God. Knowledge of a sign holds such an exalted place that the Prophet of God ص linked it to knowledge of God, as in the expression «بیت الله».
The outer limit of human knowledge is the self and the soul. That is, whatever knowledge of the external world a person attains is processed inwardly; beyond this, they have no obligation in the realm of knowledge, for the Creator does not impose an impossible burden!
Surely, the Bestower of being transcends being and cannot be described in terms of being! الله اکبر من ان یوصف. God is also too great to be described as being! Since God is the Originator, being is one of the manifestations of His blessed name الموجد; and God’s name is other than God—it is His creation!