Is it true that Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib (AS) used to perform a thousand rak‘ahs of prayer every day?
Is it true that Imam Ali ibn Abi Talib (AS) used to perform a thousand rak‘ahs of prayer every day?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Under ordinary circumstances, it would be impossible for Imam Ali (AS) to perform a thousand rak‘ahs of prayer each day: even if each rak‘ah took just two minutes, the total would exceed twenty-four hours. Although God’s friends are capable of performing miracles, worship has its value when it is performed with human faculties and in a state of calm. If this feat were accomplished through a miracle, it would not have the same devotional value in the ordinary, worldly sense.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterIf we wanted to perform a thousand rakʿahs of prayer within 24 hours, assuming we performed one rakʿah every two minutes, we would need 2,000 minutes—even though 24 hours amounts to only 1,440 minutes. And this calculation assumes that nothing else is done during those 24 hours!
Of course, all these assumptions exclude the possibility that a miracle has taken place. But if, through a miracle, the recitation of a thousand rakʿahs were accomplished, it would no longer have the same devotional value.
A continuation of the question: Perhaps it could be said that, for these revered figures, time could contract and expand. The Imam of the Age, for instance, is described in this sense as being an imam over time as well. It is also related that the sun shifted in the sky for the Prophet, and other such instances have been reported, such as on the night the Prophet صلی الله علیه و آله passed away.
This would count as a miracle. But could you explain a little how, if it were miraculous, the prayer would not have the same devotional value?
Master Ali Saei’s response to the continuation of the question: If we wanted to perform a thousand rakʿahs of prayer within 24 hours without recourse to extraordinary events or miracles, it would be practically impossible. Perhaps one could perform the prayer with great intensity and speed a few times. But given that everything the friends of God do is marked by perfect composure, dignity, and calm, performing a thousand rakʿahs under ordinary conditions would be impossible—especially if it were to be repeated every day.
There is another point, too: they move among the date palms. That movement takes time in itself, and calls for more time.
Each rakʿah of prayer performed calmly takes at least five minutes! Did the Master pray at great speed? Did the Master not sleep? Did the Master have no other work or responsibilities? Did the Master have no household affairs to attend to? And so on.
Suppose one rakʿah were performed every two minutes. Since 24 hours amounts to 1,440 minutes, 2,000 minutes would be needed. And this assumes that nothing else is done during those 24 hours!
We know that the Master Ali علیه السلام and Imam Sajjad علیه السلام were possessors of miracles and proofs. Had they wished to worship God by means of miracles, they could have performed not a thousand but millions of rakʿahs in a few seconds. But the beauty and distinctive merit of worship in this world lie in devoting oneself to God with one’s natural capacities. So if a thousand rakʿahs were performed through a miracle, they would no longer have the devotional value appropriate to the conditions of this world.
Imam Ali علیه السلام and the other Infallibles علیهم السلام were also the Proofs over the earth, time, and space. Through knowledge granted by God, they could bring time under their control. But the same point still applies: expanding time to perform a thousand rakʿahs does not add any special merit to the prayer.