⏪Is spiritual knowledge attained only through the path of self-purification?
⏪If so, did Hurr ibn Yazid al-Riyahi possess such knowledge, given that he followed the Imam (peace be upon him) in prayer?
⏪If he did, was his knowledge limited, or was he acting out of obstinacy? And how did his spiritual knowledge later deepen, leading him to join the Imam’s companions?
Is Spiritual Knowledge Attained Only Through Self-Purification?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Spiritual knowledge is not attained solely through self-purification; rather, it is the starting point of the journey and the spirit of devotion. Even after gaining such knowledge, a person remains free to choose and may still go astray, as Satan did. A seeker of spiritual knowledge must also be discerning and, guided by reason and holding fast to the Qur’an and the Prophet’s family, continue along the path of devotion.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterA mystic must be rational. How many mystics are ignorant! How many scholars are slain by their own learning!
Spiritual knowledge is like a lamp kindled in the heart. A lamp is meant to help us see, to shed light, and to set us on our way. Spiritual knowledge is the beginning of the journey, not its end; the first step toward a goal, not the last. It is the path of movement, not the destination. Spiritual knowledge is the very spirit of servanthood. We must bring worship to life in our hearts through knowledge. Once we have acquired it, we must begin the journey of servitude, whose first aims include attaining faith, certainty, and affirmation; then scaling the summit of divine oneness; and then achieving sincerity in our service to God. This, in truth, is the beginning of genuine servitude.
أول الدین معرفته و کمال معرفته التصدیق به و کمال التصدیق به توحیده و کمال توحیده الإخلاص له ...
نهج البلاغه (للصبحی صالح)، ص: 39
The beginning of religion is knowledge of Him; the perfection of that knowledge is affirming Him; the perfection of affirming Him is declaring His oneness; and the perfection of declaring His oneness is sincerity toward Him…
It is possible to go astray after attaining knowledge, just as Satan became an unbeliever despite all his learning and worship.
قال رسول الله ص ثلاث أخافهن على أمتی من بعدی الضلاله بعد المعرفه و مضلات الفتن و شهوه البطن و الفرج.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج2، ص: 80
The Messenger of God, peace be upon him, said: “I fear only three things for you: going astray after attaining knowledge, the misguidance of tribulations, and the appetites of the belly and the sexual organs.”
The remedy is for a mystic to be rational: that is, to place himself under the guidance of reason and follow it. The surest sign of being guided by reason is holding fast to the Qur’an and the Prophet’s Household.
Spiritual knowledge should be regarded as the foundation and starting point of human action. Of course, it has degrees, and the higher one rises through them, the greater the worth of one’s actions.
For spiritual knowledge to have its fullest effect, the soul must be purified of vices and adorned with noble virtues.
Knowledge does not take away a person’s freedom to choose; rather, it strengthens it. In other words, even with profound knowledge, a mystic may still choose falsehood. When he chooses the truth, he is a rational mystic; if he chooses falsehood, he is an ignorant one. In fact, if a mystic chooses reason to lead him, he is rational; if he chooses ignorance as his leader, he is ignorant. The noble Hurr initially possessed knowledge, but he followed ignorance, as was outwardly evident in his obedience to Yazid. In the end, however, he accepted the leadership of reason, as was outwardly evident in his obedience to Imam Husayn, peace be upon him.
قلت یا أمیر المؤمنین ما الإیمان و ما الإسلام قال أما الإیمان فالإقرار بالمعرفه و الإسلام فما أقررت به «50» و التسلیم و الطاعه لهم قلت الإیمان الإقرار بعد المعرفه به قال من عرفه الله نفسه و نبیه و إمامه ثم أقر بطاعته فهو مؤمن قلت المعرفه من الله و الإقرار من العبد قال المعرفه من الله [دعاء] «52» و حجه و [منه و نعمه] و الإقرار [من الله] «54» قبول العبد- یمن على من یشاء و المعرفه صنع الله تعالى فی القلب و الإقرار [فعال القلب] «55» من الله و عصمته و رحمته فمن لم یجعله [الله] «56» عارفا فلا حجه علیه و علیه أن یقف و یکف عما لا یعلم فلا یعذبه الله على جهله ...
کتاب سلیم بن قیس الهلالی، ج2، ص: 610
I asked, “Commander of the Faithful, what are faith and Islam?” He replied, “Faith is affirming what one knows; Islam is what you have affirmed, together with submission and obedience to them.” I asked, “Does faith mean affirming something after coming to know it?” He replied, “Whoever is brought by God to know Him, His Prophet, and his Imam, and then affirms his obedience to them, is a believer.” I asked, “Does knowledge come from God and affirmation from the servant?” He replied, “Knowledge comes from God as a summons, a proof, a favor, and a blessing. Affirmation is God’s acceptance of the servant—He bestows His favor on whomever He wills. Knowledge is God’s work in the heart, while affirmation is an act of the heart, and [it comes] from God, His protection, and His mercy. Whoever God has not made knowledgeable is not accountable; he must refrain and hold back from what he does not know, and God will not punish him for his ignorance…”
عبد الملک بن أعین سألت عن المعرفه ما هی فاعلم رحمک الله أن المعرفه من صنع الله عز و جل فی القلب مخلوقه و الجحود صنع الله فی القلب مخلوق «1» و لیس للعباد فیهما من صنع و لهم فیهما الاختیار من الاکتساب فبشهوتهم الإیمان اختاروا المعرفه فکانوا بذلک مؤمنین عارفین و بشهوتهم الکفر اختاروا الجحود فکانوا بذلک کافرین جاحدین ضلالا و ذلک بتوفیق الله لهم و خذلان من خذله الله فبالاختیار و الاکتساب عاقبهم الله و أثابهم
التوحید (للصدوق)، ص: 226
“Know—may God have mercy on you—that spiritual knowledge is something God creates in the heart, and denial is likewise something God creates in the heart. Human beings have no part in bringing either of them into being, but they are free to acquire one or the other by choice. If they desire faith, they choose knowledge and thereby become believers who know. If they desire unbelief, they choose denial and thereby become unbelievers, deniers, and lost. Both outcomes come about through God’s granting success to some and abandoning those He abandons. It is on account of their choice and what they acquire that God punishes them or rewards them.”
و قال ع رب عالم قد قتله جهله و علمه معه [لم ینفعه] لا ینفعه
نهج البلاغه (للصبحی صالح)، ص: 487