Thank you for your efforts. Regarding the chain of transmission of the Supplication of Arafah, its narrators are the sons of Ghalib al-Asadi. Is their report enough to establish its reliability? Did the Imams after Imam Husayn (AS) affirm this supplication? Its prayers have such unparalleled meaning that they could not have come from anyone other than an infallible. Thank you.
Is the Chain of Transmission of the Supplication of Arafah Reliable?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The sons of Ghalib al-Asadi, who are among the narrators of the Supplication of Arafah, are unknown and have not been authenticated by leading scholars of rijal. Their report alone, therefore, is not sufficient to establish its reliability. Nevertheless, the supplication’s unparalleled themes—which express the depth of Husayn’s anguish and its effect on all of existence—indicate that it came from an infallible source. The Imams who came after Imam Husayn (AS) also affirmed it.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe sons of Ghalib do not establish the reliability of the supplication in question, since they are unknown narrators and no statements accrediting them by leading scholars of narrator evaluation have been reported.
**The chain of transmission and heartfelt authentication**
When even stone, moved by love and grief for Master Abu ʿAbd Allah al-Husayn, sheds tears of blood, and water, wind, rain, the sea and its fish, and the sky in all its vastness … are shattered and burn with Husayni grief, it is hardly surprising that a sound heart should sense the fragrance of the Imam’s words at the heart of the Prayer of ʿArafah. A heart unfamiliar with his words is no heart at all; a stone is far better than that!
Indeed, the Imam’s beauty shines forth in all its splendour through the frame of the Prayer of ʿArafah!
**The Sermon of Zayn al-Abidin (peace be upon him) at the entrance to Medina**
فقال الحمد لله رب العالمین- مالک یوم الدین بارئ الخلائق أجمعین الذی بعد فارتفع فی السماوات العلى و قرب فشهد النجوى نحمده على عظائم الأمور و فجائع الدهور و جلیل الرزء و عظیم المصائب أیها القوم إن الله و له الحمد ابتلانا بمصیبه جلیله و ثلمه فی الإسلام عظیمه قتل أبو عبد الله و عترته و سبی نساؤه و صبیته و داروا برأسه فی البلدان من فوق عالی السنان أیها الناس فأی رجالات منکم یسرون بعد قتله أم أیه عین تحبس دمعها و تصن عن انهمالها فلقد بکت السبع الشداد لقتله و بکت البحار و السماوات و الأرض و الأشجار و الحیتان و الملائکه المقربون و أهل السماوات أجمعون أیها الناس أی قلب لا یتصدع لقتله أم أی فؤاد لا یحن إلیه أم أی سمع یسمع هذه الثلمه التی ثلمت فی الإسلام أیها الناس أصبحنا مطرودین مشردین مذودین شاسعین کأنا أولاد ترک أو کابل من غیر جرم اجترمناه و لا مکروه ارتکبناه- ما سمعنا بهذا فی آبائنا الأولین- إن هذا إلا اختلاق و الله لو أن النبی تقدم إلیهم فی قتالنا کما تقدم إلیهم فی الوصاه بنا لما زادوا على ما فعلوه- ف إنا لله و إنا إلیه راجعون فقام إلیه صوحان بن صعصعه بن صوحان و کان زمنا فاعتذر إلیه فقبل عذره و شکر له و ترحم على أبیه.
مثیر الأحزان, p. 113.