Peace be upon you. The Messenger of God, peace and blessings be upon him and his family, said:
من تقدم علی قوم من المسلمین و هو یری أن فیهم من هو أفضل منه فقد خان الله و رسوله و المسلمین .
Whoever takes precedence over a group of Muslims while knowing that there is someone more worthy than him among them has betrayed God, His Messenger, and all the Muslims.
The sources are exclusively from Sunni books: …Tamheed, by Baqillani, 190. Similar reports appear in other Sunni books: …Kanz al-‘Ummal, 6/25 …Sunan al-Bayhaqi, 10/118 …Jami‘ al-Saghir, by Suyuti, 1/455. Is the hadith sound according to Shi‘i standards of transmission? If it is sound, how can one take precedence over the Imam of the Age (AJ) in order to establish a just government?
Is the hadith “من تقدم علی قوم…” sound in its chain of transmission, and how is it compatible with the imamate of Imam of the Age (AJ)?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The hadith “من تقدم علی قوم من المسلمین و هو یری أن فیهم من هو أفضل منه فقد خان الله و رسوله و المسلمین” has no reliable chain of transmission in Shi‘i sources. Even if it did have a chain, its narrators are non-Imami and not trustworthy. It is misguided to compare this hadith with the establishment of government during the Occultation: unjust caliphs were usurpers, whereas during the Occultation the qualified jurist is charged with establishing a religious government. This does not mean taking precedence over the Imam of the Age (AJ), but rather carrying out God’s commands and establishing justice.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe establishment of a just government is like strewing flowers to welcome the Imam of justice and equity.
The hadith cited above is given without a chain of transmission. Even if it did have a chain, since its narrators are non-Imami and not reliable, one could expect the chain to be weak. As for its meaning, however, it is reasonable and, when applied to the position of the unjust caliphs in relation to the Mawla, entirely sound and commendable.
But comparing the message of this hadith with the question of government during the Occultation is a false analogy.
First, the caliphs had usurped the Mawla’s right—or, in other words, had staged a coup—and had wrongfully taken up the position that rightfully belonged to him. This does not apply during the Occultation. The religious authorities, who are in fact transmitters of hadith and, at the same time, the Imam’s general deputies and his proof to all humanity, make the presence of a just jurist-governor in society indispensable to fulfilling the wishes of the Master of the Age, سلام الله علیه. Our individual lives are not separate from or independent of society; they are bound up with it and affected by it. To safeguard our religious well-being, a religious government must therefore be established, and it is the duty of an eminent and qualified religious scholar to bring this about.
Establishing a just government is the duty of the religious ruler. This does not mean getting ahead of the Imam of the Age, علیه السلام, since upholding justice is, in reality, acting in accordance with the Quran and the commands of the Ahl al-Bayt, علیهم السلام. Justice cannot be established except through the formation of a just government.
یا أیها الذین آمنوا کونوا قوامین لله شهداء بالقسط و لا یجرمنکم شنآن قوم على ألا تعدلوا اعدلوا هو أقرب للتقوى و اتقوا الله إن الله خبیر بما تعملون
O you who believe, stand steadfast for God and bear witness with justice. Do not let your enmity toward a people lead you to sin by departing from justice. Be just; that is nearer to piety. And be mindful of God: God is fully aware of what you do.
Upholding justice and establishing a just government are divine commands addressed to all believers. The faithful ruler stands at the forefront of putting this noble verse into practice. Yet it is certain that a just world government, in all its aspects, will be established only through بقیه الله الاعظم.
Second, if someone regards the establishment of a just government during the Occultation as getting ahead of the Imam of the Age, علیه السلام, then they would have to accept the establishment of an unjust government. That would amount to taking action against God, His Messenger, and God’s wali.