The views and arguments of the mystics mentioned in their analysis of the wisdom behind the pressure of the grave have no scientific basis!
They interpret the struggle between life and death as the pressure of the grave, even though this pressure occurs after death, not in the interval before it!
When someone’s soul is taken, they have no power to prevent it; they are entirely helpless!
Dying is sweet for believers (though some may, of course, suffer hardship as expiation for certain sins), and bitter for unbelievers!
There is no pressure of the grave for those who love the Ahl al-Bayt علیهم السلام!
Seeing their rank in the abode of the hereafter makes a believer impatient for death to come quickly!
The body subjected to pressure is the imaginal, or barzakh, body. It is like the physical body, but its nature is neither material nor immaterial; rather, it lies between the two! The soul enters it after death!
و اعلم أن لکل ظاهر باطنا على مثاله فما طاب ظاهره طاب باطنه و ما خبث ظاهره خبث باطنه
نهج البلاغه (للصبحی صالح), p. 216
Imam Ali علیه السلام says that every outward has an inward resembling it: if the outward is pure, so is the inward; and if the outward is impure, so is the inward!
قد روی عن الصادق ع ما ذکرناه فی هذا المعنى و بیناه
Imam al-Sadiq (علیه السلام) was asked about what happens to the soul of someone who dies in this world. He replied: “When a person dies wholly devoted to faith or wholly devoted to disbelief, the soul is transferred from the body to another like it in form, and is requited for its deeds until the Day of Resurrection. When God raises those in the graves, He creates their bodies, returns their souls to them, and raises them up to requite them for their deeds. The soul of the believer passes from the body into another body of the same form, and is placed in one of the gardens of Paradise, where it enjoys bliss until the Day of Return. The soul of the unbeliever passes from the body into another exactly like it, and is placed in a Fire, where it is punished until the Day of Resurrection.”
بحار الأنوار (ط - بیروت)، ج6، ص: 253
...یا عباد الله ما بعد الموت لمن لم یغفر له أشد من الموت القبر فاحذروا ضیقه و ضنکه و ظلمته و غربته إن القبر یقول کل یوم أنا بیت الغربه أنا بیت التراب أنا بیت الوحشه أنا بیت الدود و الهوام و القبر روضه من ریاض الجنه أو حفره من حفر النار «1» إن العبد المؤمن إذا دفن قالت الأرض له مرحبا و أهلا قد کنت ممن أحب أن یمشی على ظهری فإذا تولیتک فستعلم کیف صنعی بک «2» فتتسع له مد البصر و إن الکافر إذا دفن قالت الأرض له لا مرحبا و لا أهلا قد کنت من أبغض من یمشی على ظهری فإذا تولیتک فستعلم کیف صنعی بک فتضمه حتى تلتقی أضلاعه- و إن المعیشه الضنک التی حذر الله منها عدوه عذاب القبر أن یسلط الله على الکافر فی قبره تسعه و تسعین تنینا فینهشن لحمه و یکسرن عظمه- یترددن علیه کذلک إلى یوم یبعث لو أن تنینا منها نفخ فی الأرض لم تنبت زرعا أبدا-...
الأمالی (للمفید)، النص، ص: 265
...
Servants of God! There is no escape from death. So fear it before it comes, and make ready for it, for you are within death’s reach, its prey. If you remain, it will seize you; if you flee, it will catch up with you. Death is closer to you than your own shadow, and stays by your side. It is bound up with your very locks, while the world is being rolled away behind your heels, shortening your lives moment by moment. So whenever your souls draw you towards their desires, remember death often. Remembering death is counsel enough, and the Messenger of God (PBUH) would often urge his companions to remember it, saying:
“Remember death often, for death shatters pleasures and stands between you and your desires.”
Servants of God! For one who has not been forgiven, death is followed by something even more dreadful: the grave. So beware its narrowness and pressure, its darkness and loneliness. Every day the grave says: “I am the home of loneliness; I am the house of dust; I am the house of desolation; I am the home of worms and vermin.” The grave is either a garden from among the gardens of Paradise or a pit from among the pits of Hell. When a believing servant is laid in the earth, the earth says to him: “Welcome! You are one of those I loved to see walking upon my back. Now that I have taken you in, you will see how I treat you!” Then it expands for him as far as the eye can see. But when an unbeliever is laid in the earth, it says to him: “No welcome to you! You were among those I hated most to see walking upon my back. Now that I have taken you in, you will see how I treat you!” Then it squeezes him until his ribs press together.
The grievous life that God has warned His enemy about is the punishment of the grave: God sets ninety-nine dragons upon the unbeliever in his grave. They bite at his flesh and break his bones, continually coming and going over him until the day he is raised from the grave. Were one of those dragons to breathe upon the earth, it would never again grow a crop.
Servants of God! Know that your frail souls and your delicate, pampered bodies cannot endure such torment; even a little of it would be enough to overwhelm them. So, if you can show mercy to your bodies and souls, sparing them what they cannot bear or endure, then do what God loves and leave what He abhors.
Servants of God! After you are raised from the grave, you will face something even more dreadful than the punishment of the grave: a Day...
الأمالی (للمفید) / ترجمه استاد ولى، متن، ص: 29
It is Imam Ali (AS) who says:
«فلو مثلتهم بعقلک، أو کشف عنهم محجوب الغطاء لک، و قد ارتسخت أسماعهم بالهوام فاستکت، واکتحلت أبصارهم بالتراب فخسفت، و تقطعت الألسنه فی أفواههم بعد ذلاقتها، و همدت القلوب فی صدورهم بعد یقظتها، و عاث فی کل جارحه منهم جدید بلى سمجها، و سهل طرق الآفه إلیها، مستسلمات فلا أید تدفع ولا قلوب تجزع، لرأیت أشجان قلوب و أقذاء عیون، لهم فی کل فظاعه صفه حال لا تنتقل، و غمره لا تنجلی؛»
Nahj al-Balagha (ed. Subhi Salih), p. 340
“If you were to picture the dead with your mind’s eye, or if the veil of dust that conceals them from you were lifted, you would see them with their ears destroyed and deafened by the creatures that had burrowed into them; their eyes sunk into their heads, their sight clouded by the dust; their tongues torn to pieces in their mouths, though once sharp and eloquent; their hearts stilled in their breasts, though once alert. In each of their limbs, fresh decay has set in, bringing corruption and disfigurement, and making the way for destruction easy. They lie helpless, unable to raise a hand in defence against pain and illness, or to find a heart with which to lament their suffering. If you looked with the eye of reflection, you would see the grief in their hearts and the debris and gore in their eyes. For each of them, in every kind of humiliation and affliction, there is a state that will not change, and a distress that will not lift.”
(Ansari’s Translation of Nahj al-Balagha, p. 625)
اللهم إنی أعوذ بک من عذاب القبر و من ضیق القبر و من ضغطه القبر
O God, I seek refuge in You from the torment, constriction and pressure of the grave. (Makarim al-Akhlaq, supplication for morning and evening)
«قال رسول الله صلی الله علیه و آله ضغطه القبر للمؤمن کفاره لما کان منه من تضییع النعم
(أمالی الصدوق،540)؛
The Messenger of God (peace and blessings be upon him and his family) said: “The pressure of the grave is an expiation for the believer’s neglect of blessings.”
(Amaali al-Saduq, 540)
More details will follow in discussions to come, God willing.
-1
Does the pressure of the grave really exist?
The meaning of the pressure of the grave from the perspective of mysticism:
At the moment of death, the soul’s separation from the body is certain and takes place in a fraction of a second. It happens so quickly that even someone whose eyes are open at the moment of death has no time to close them. One of the sweetest experiences a person has is precisely the moment the soul leaves the body: a sensation of becoming weightless and suspended.
After death, the first thing that happens is that our soul—which includes a part that is like the mind’s aura and is, in fact, an archive of information about its life in this world—begins reviewing that life, from birth to the moment of death. The images of that life are replayed for the soul like a film. We might imagine that this takes a very long time. But time is really a convention created by us human beings. We are the ones who have agreed that each minute consists of sixty seconds. In reality, time goes beyond these definitions.
As the soul reviews its life, the first thing that catches its attention is the attachments the person formed throughout life. Some of these attachments had even been forgotten while the person was alive, but at this stage they surface again. The degree and level of worldly attachment varies from person to person.
From among its memories, the soul identifies its attachments. These attachments may be positive or negative. For example, attachment to worldly wealth is negative, while a mother’s attachment to her child is a kind of positive love and attachment. But either way, it is an attachment.
These attachments create a downward pull on the soul, preventing it from moving toward the guide who would lead it out of the worldly stage. In other words, after death the soul is subject to two opposing pulls: the force of attachment drawing it downward, and the force beckoning it toward the next stage. If the force of attachment prevails, the soul is drawn toward re-entering the body. Unable to let go of its attachments, it wants to experience them again. So the soul moves toward the body and tries to persuade the dead body to receive it again. The pressure placed on the “soul” as it tries to persuade its own body is, in fact, the pressure of the grave. This pressure is in no way exerted on the body, since the body has died and feels no pain. The pressure of the grave is therefore the pressure of attachment, and has nothing to do with whether a person has a grave or not. Nor does it have anything to do with the earthly night; it can begin from the very moment of death.
One reason the deceased is prompted with the words of the talqin is to help them accept that they have died and not try to return.
After a while, the soul realizes that its efforts are futile, and the pressure of the grave subsides.
Imam Ali (AS):
“Live as though you will be alive for a thousand years, and live as though you will die tomorrow…”
Attachments may prevent the soul from passing beyond this stage for years. The idea of wandering souls and the heaviness felt in graveyards is due to these very attachments. Sometimes, for years, the deceased cannot let go of their attachment to their grave and to the body of which nothing now remains.
May we come to understand the meaning of this poem:
The world is nothing, and all the world’s affairs are nothing;
O you who are nothing, for nothing, do not toil over nothing…
Let go and move on.
Look, but do not become attached.
Cast your eyes upon it, but do not stake your heart on it.
Sooner or later, we must leave it all behind and move on…
Master Ali Saei’s answer to question 111-1
The statements and views of the mystics cited in explaining the wisdom behind the pressure of the grave have no scientific basis!
They interpret the struggle between life and death as the pressure of the grave, even though this pressure occurs after death, not in the midst of it!
When a person’s soul is taken, they have no power to prevent it; they are entirely helpless!
For believers, dying is sweet (though some may suffer hardship as expiation for certain sins), while for unbelievers it is bitter!
For those who love اهل بیت علیهم السلام, there is no pressure in the grave!
A believer, having seen their station in the next world, is impatient for death to come quickly!
The body that undergoes this pressure is the imaginal, or barzakhi, body. It is like a body, but its nature is neither material nor immaterial; rather, it lies between the two! After death, the soul enters it!
و اعلم أن لکل ظاهر باطنا على مثاله فما طاب ظاهره طاب باطنه و ما خبث ظاهره خبث باطنه
نهج البلاغه (للصبحی صالح)، ص: 216
Imam Ali علیه السلام says: “For every outward aspect there is an inward aspect like it. If the outward is pure, the inward is pure too; and if the outward is vile, the inward is vile too!”
قد روی عن الصادق ع ما ذکرناه فی هذا المعنى و بیناه
فسئل عمن مات فی هذه الدار أین تکون روحه فقال من مات و هو ماحض للإیمان محضا أو ماحض للکفر محضا نقلت روحه من هیکله إلى مثله فی الصوره و جوزی بأعماله إلى یوم القیامه فإذا بعث الله من فی القبور أنشأ جسمه و رد روحه إلى جسده و حشره لیوفیه أعماله فالمؤمن ینتقل روحه من جسده إلى مثل جسده فی الصوره فیجعل فی جنات من جنان الدنیا یتنعم فیها إلى یوم المآب و الکافر ینتقل روحه من جسده إلى مثله بعینه و یجعل فی نار فیعذب بها إلى یوم القیامه.
بحار الأنوار (ط - بیروت)، ج6، ص: 253
Imam al-Sadiq (علیه السلام) was asked about someone who dies in this world: Where will his soul be? He replied: When a wholly sincere believer or a wholly hardened disbeliever dies, their souls are transferred from their bodies to forms like them, and they are requited for their deeds, good or evil, until the Resurrection. When God raises those in the graves, He fashions their bodies, returns their souls to them, and gathers them so that He may requite them for their deeds, which have become blessings or punishment. Thus, the believer’s soul is transferred from his body to a body resembling its former shape, and he is placed in one of the gardens of this world, where he will enjoy its blessings until the Day of Return. The disbeliever’s soul is transferred from his body to a body just like it, and he is placed in the Fire, where he will suffer punishment until the Resurrection.
...یا عباد الله ما بعد الموت لمن لم یغفر له أشد من الموت القبر فاحذروا ضیقه و ضنکه و ظلمته و غربته إن القبر یقول کل یوم أنا بیت الغربه أنا بیت التراب أنا بیت الوحشه أنا بیت الدود و الهوام و القبر روضه من ریاض الجنه أو حفره من حفر النار «1» إن العبد المؤمن إذا دفن قالت الأرض له مرحبا و أهلا قد کنت ممن أحب أن یمشی على ظهری فإذا تولیتک فستعلم کیف صنعی بک «2» فتتسع له مد البصر و إن الکافر إذا دفن قالت الأرض له لا مرحبا و لا أهلا قد کنت من أبغض من یمشی على ظهری فإذا تولیتک فستعلم کیف صنعی بک فتضمه حتى تلتقی أضلاعه- و إن المعیشه الضنک التی حذر الله منها عدوه عذاب القبر أن یسلط الله على الکافر فی قبره تسعه و تسعین تنینا فینهشن لحمه و یکسرن عظمه- یترددن علیه کذلک إلى یوم یبعث لو أن تنینا منها نفخ فی الأرض لم تنبت زرعا أبدا-...
الأمالی (للمفید)، النص، ص: 265
...
Servants of God! Death cannot be escaped. So be mindful of it before it comes, and prepare for it, for you are within death’s reach. If you remain, it will seize you; if you flee, it will catch up with you. Death is closer to you and more constant than your shadow; it is entwined with your forelock, and the world is slipping away behind you, diminishing your lives moment by moment. So, whenever your souls draw you toward desire, remember death often. Death is counsel enough, and the Messenger of God (PBUH) often urged his companions to remember death, saying:
“Remember death often, for death shatters pleasures and comes between you and your desires.”
Servants of God! For one who has not been forgiven, there is nothing after death more dreadful than the grave. So beware of its narrowness and pressure, its darkness and loneliness. Every day the grave says: “I am the home of loneliness; I am the home of dust; I am the home of desolation; I am the home of worms and creeping creatures. The grave is either a garden among the gardens of Paradise or a pit among the pits of Hell.” When a believing servant is laid in the earth, it says to him: “Welcome, you are most welcome! You were one of those I loved to see walking upon my back. Now that I have taken you into my care, you will see how I treat you.” Then the grave expands for him as far as the eye can see. But when a disbeliever is laid in the earth, it says to him: “You are not welcome; may you find no welcome here! You were among those I most despised seeing walk upon my back. Now that I have taken you into my care, you will see how I treat you.” Then it presses him until his ribs meet.
The grievous life of hardship from which God warns His enemy is the punishment of the grave: God sets ninety-nine dragons upon the disbeliever in his grave. They bite at his flesh and break his bones, returning to him again and again in this way until the day he is raised. If even one of those dragons breathed upon the earth, it would never again grow a crop.
Servants of God! Know that your frail souls and pampered, delicate bodies cannot endure all this torment; even a little of it would be enough to overwhelm them. So, if you can show compassion to these bodies and souls of yours, which cannot bear or endure what lies beyond their strength, then do what God loves and leave what God dislikes.
Servants of God! Know that after being raised from the grave, you will face something more dreadful than the punishment of the grave: the Day...
الأمالی (للمفید) / ترجمه استاد ولى، متن، ص: 29
It is Imam Ali (peace be upon him) who said:
«فلو مثلتهم بعقلک، أو کشف عنهم محجوب الغطاء لک، و قد ارتسخت أسماعهم بالهوام فاستکت، واکتحلت أبصارهم بالتراب فخسفت، و تقطعت الألسنه فی أفواههم بعد ذلاقتها، و همدت القلوب فی صدورهم بعد یقظتها، و عاث فی کل جارحه منهم جدید بلى سمجها، و سهل طرق الآفه إلیها، مستسلمات فلا أید تدفع ولا قلوب تجزع، لرأیت أشجان قلوب و أقذاء عیون، لهم فی کل فظاعه صفه حال لا تنتقل، و غمره لا تنجلی؛»
نهج البلاغه (للصبحی صالح)، ص: 340
If you were to picture those dead with the eye of reason, or if the veil of dust that conceals them from you were lifted, you would see their ears stopped up and deafened by the creatures that had burrowed into them; their eyes sunk beneath the dust that had settled in them; their tongues torn apart in their mouths, though once quick and sharp; and their hearts, once alert, stilled in their breasts. Fresh decay had taken hold in every limb, defiling and disfiguring it, while the way was made easy for its destruction. They lay helpless, unable to lift a hand in their defence or find a heart that could cry out in anguish. Were you to look with an eye that takes warning, you would see the grief in their hearts and the filth in their eyes. In every horror and affliction, their condition remains unchanged, and their distress never lifts.
(Ansari’s translation of Nahj al-Balagha, p. 625)
اللهم إنی أعوذ بک من عذاب القبر و من ضیق القبر و من ضغطه القبر
O God, I seek refuge in You from the punishment, the constriction and the pressure of the grave.
(Makarim al-Akhlaq, a supplication for every morning and evening)
«قال رسول الله صلی الله علیه و آله ضغطه القبر للمؤمن کفاره لما کان منه من تضییع النعم
(أمالی الصدوق،540)؛
The Messenger of God (peace and blessings be upon him and his family) said: “The pressure of the grave is an expiation for the believer’s neglect of the blessings he was given.”
More on this in discussions to come, ان شاء الله تعالی.