Teacher, is this account true: that the Maghrib prayer used to be two rak‘ahs, and when the Prophet was told of Lady Fatima’s birth after he had finished the prayer, a rak‘ah was added, making it three?
Was the Maghrib Prayer Originally Two Rak‘ahs, and Was a Third Added on the Occasion of Lady Fatima’s Birth?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The Maghrib prayer was originally two rak‘ahs, and one rak‘ah was added. According to the narrations, this addition was made because it was the time when Adam repented and his supplication was answered. No narration has been found stating that the additional rak‘ah was added on the occasion of Lady Fatima’s birth. The prayer was originally one rak‘ah, which was completed by adding a second; later, because the prayers were not being performed in full, two rak‘ahs were added to the Dhuhr, Asr, and Isha prayers.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterPrayer was originally two rakʿahs at each of its prescribed times. The Messenger of God, inspired by the needs of the community, added seven rakʿahs to the prayers: two each to ẓuhr, ʿaṣr and ʿishāʾ, and one to maghrib, while leaving the dawn prayer unchanged. The reason for adding one rakʿah to the maghrib prayer is given in the hadith below. However, I have not found a hadith concerning the reason you mentioned!×
و أما صلاه المغرب فهی الساعه التی تاب الله عز و جل فیها على آدم ع و کان بین ما أکل من الشجره و بین ما تاب الله عز و جل علیه ثلاثمائه سنه من أیام الدنیا و فی أیام الآخره یوم کألف سنه ما بین العصر إلى العشاء «1» و صلى آدم ع ثلاث رکعات رکعه لخطیئته و رکعه لخطیئه حواء و رکعه لتوبته «2» ففرض الله عز و جل هذه الثلاث رکعات على أمتی و هی الساعه التی یستجاب فیها الدعاء فوعدنی ربی عز و جل أن یستجیب لمن دعاه فیها و هی الصلاه التی أمرنی ربی بها فی قوله تبارک و تعالى- فسبحان الله حین تمسون و حین تصبحون
من لا یحضره الفقیه، ج1، ص: 213
The maghrib prayer is for the hour in which God, Mighty and Exalted, forgave Adam (peace be upon him) and accepted his repentance. Three hundred years of worldly time passed between Adam’s eating from the tree and God, Mighty and Exalted, accepting his repentance. In the time of the Hereafter, a day is like a thousand years; this interval extended from ʿaṣr until nightfall. Adam (peace be upon him) performed three rakʿahs: one for his own sin, one for Eve’s sin, and one in gratitude for his repentance. God, Mighty and Exalted, therefore made these three rakʿahs obligatory for my community. This is an hour in which supplications are answered, and my Lord, Mighty and Exalted, promised me that He would answer whoever called upon Him at that time. It is the prayer my Lord commanded me to perform in His words, exalted and glorified is He:
فسبحان الله حین تمسون و حین تصبحون
That is: “So glorify God when you enter the evening and when you rise in the morning” (al-Rūm 30:17).
من لا یحضره الفقیه / ترجمه غفارى، على اکبر ومحمد جواد و بلاغى، صدر، ج1، ص: 318
عن الفضل بن شاذان عن الرضا ع قال: إنما جعل أصل الصلاه رکعتین و زید على بعضها رکعه و على بعضها رکعتان و لم یزد على بعضها شیء لأن أصل الصلاه إنما هی رکعه واحده لأن أصل العدد واحد فإذا نقصت من واحد فلیست هی صلاه فعلم الله عز و جل أن العباد لا یؤدون تلک الرکعه الواحده التی لا صلاه أقل منها بکمالها و تمامها و الإقبال علیها فقرن إلیها رکعه أخرى لیتم بالثانیه ما نقص من الأولى ففرض الله عز و جل أصل الصلاه رکعتین ثم علم رسول الله ص أن العباد لا یؤدون هاتین الرکعتین بتمام ما أمروا به و کماله فضم إلى الظهر و العصر و العشاء الآخره رکعتین رکعتين لیکون فیها تمام الرکعتین الأولتین
وسائل الشیعه، ج4، ص: 53
Imam al-Riḍā (peace be upon him) said: “The foundation of the prayer was made two rakʿahs. One rakʿah was added to some prayers, two to others, and nothing was added to the rest. This is because the prayer’s original foundation is a single rakʿah, just as the basic number is one. If it were reduced below one, it would no longer be a prayer. God, Mighty and Exalted, knew that His servants would not perform that single rakʿah—the minimum prayer requires—with full measure, completeness and attentiveness. So He joined another rakʿah to it, allowing the second to make up for what was lacking in the first. Thus God, Mighty and Exalted, prescribed two rakʿahs as the foundation of the prayer. Then the Messenger of God (peace and blessings be upon him and his family) knew that the servants would not perform these two rakʿahs with the full measure and completeness required of them. So he added two rakʿahs to each of ẓuhr, ʿaṣr and the night prayer, so that these would complete the first two rakʿahs.”