#Follow-up_Question2484
Peace be upon you, respected teacher. I sent your answer to the teacher, who was pleased to hear that shirk concerns one’s intention, not one’s words. Since you mentioned at the end of your message that your answer was not yet complete, I am sending you the rest for review. Thank you.
Hello, and I hope you’re well.
1. I, too, previously thought that shirk was a matter of intention. But recently, considering the lexical meaning of the word shirk—which, in its broad sense, includes more than intention—and certain narrations whose apparent wording considers outward actions when describing someone as guilty of shirk, I have come to the conclusion that seeking one’s needs from someone other than God (directing one’s supplication to someone other than God) is shirk even without intending that the other person acts independently of God. I quote one such narration below:
Imam al-Sadiq, peace be upon him:
《لایکون العبد مشرکا" حتی یصلی لغیر الله او یذبح لغیر الله او یدعو لغیر الله عز و جل》
A person does not become a polytheist until they:
- pray to someone other than God;
- offer a sacrifice to someone other than God;
- supplicate to someone other than God
(direct their supplication to someone other than God).
[خصال صدوق/باب الثلاثه/Hadith 151]
2. Ordinary seeking of help and devotional seeking of help should not be treated as the same. Since devotional seeking of help is an act of worship, it is governed by revealed law, and the default rule is that it is impermissible unless permission is granted by the Sacred Lawgiver. Not only is there no such permission in the verses or “authoritative narrations” to direct one’s supplication to someone other than God, but this is strongly prohibited. The noble verse إیاک نستعین alone is sufficient to establish this prohibition.
Of course, there is no prohibition on seeking ordinary help from someone other than God. Since it is not an act of worship, it does not require permission from the Sacred Lawgiver in the first place.
The distinction between ordinary seeking of help (seeking healing through medicine) and devotional seeking of help (asking God for healing) should be clear to every fair-minded and reasonable person.