Summary of the question raised
Does repeatedly having the same dream mean that one should take a particular action? What is the criterion for recognising a true dream?
Full text of the question
According to the following account, which is taken from the words of Ayatollah Ziaabadi:
“An examination was under way, and the Prophet Abraham (peace be upon him) dreamt that he was sacrificing his thirteen-year-old son—that is, cutting his throat. Of course, the dreams of prophets (peace be upon them) are a form of revelation and are unlike the dreams of ordinary people; they cannot be compared. This dream recurred for three nights. On the third occasion, Abraham (peace be upon him) told his son Ishmael (peace be upon him) about it and said:
(...یا بنی إنی أری فی المنام أنی أذبحک فانظر ما ذا تری...)؛[17]
‘…My dear son, I see in a dream that I am sacrificing you…’
That is, ‘I see myself as having been commanded by God to sacrifice you. Now consider what you think about this.’ The thirteen-year-old did not say, ‘Father, what have I done to deserve being killed?’”
And now the question:
A point to note:
(((It is true that the discussion as a whole concerns sacrificing the commanding self, but it also encompasses several different dimensions.)))
Could a dream’s repetition mean that we ought to do something? For example, if ordinary people have the same dream several times, can we take that as evidence that we should do a particular thing?
Did the Prophet Abraham have this dream three nights in a row, or on separate occasions?
What is the criterion for distinguishing a satanic dream from other kinds of dreams? Why did the Prophet not regard this dream as satanic after seeing it several times? After all, Satan has a long reach and can interfere everywhere!
Taking into account that people differ in whether or not they are infallible, what are the conditions of a dream that should be given heed? Can repetition alone, or a person’s physical and emotional state—for example, dreaming about an issue that has left one confused—affect whether a dream should be taken into account?