Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 336 17 July 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Advanced

What Hadith Evidence Can Establish That the Infallibles Rank Above the Prophets?

Primary reference: See the answer text 38 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

A report from Imam Ali (AS), transmitted from the Prophet (PBUH), states that God first created the spirits of the Prophet’s Household (AS), and that the angels learned the oneness of God by glorifying Him through them. The angels also prostrated before Adam because the Prophet’s Household (AS) was present in his loins. During the Ascension, the Prophet (PBUH) recognized his successors as twelve lights: the first was Ali (AS), and the last was the Mahdi (AJ).

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

From his father, Ali ibn Abi Talib (peace be upon him), who said: The Messenger of God (peace and blessings be upon him and his family) said: God has not created any creature more excellent than me, nor any more honored before Him than me. Ali (peace be upon him) said: I said, "O Messenger of God, are you more excellent or Gabriel?" He said: "O Ali, God, blessed and exalted, favored His sent prophets over His angels brought near, and favored me over all the prophets and messengers. And excellence after me belongs to you, O Ali, and to the Imams after you. The angels are indeed our servants and the servants of those who love us. O Ali, those who bear the Throne and those around it glorify their Lord with praise ... and seek forgiveness for those who believe in our guardianship. O Ali, were it not for us, God would not have created Adam, nor Eve, nor Paradise, nor Hell, nor the heaven, nor the earth. So how should we not be more excellent than the angels, when we preceded them in knowing our Lord, glorifying Him, declaring His oneness, and sanctifying Him? For the first thing God, mighty and majestic, created was our spirits, and He made us speak of His oneness and His praise. Then He created the angels, and when they beheld our spirits as a single light, they regarded our affair as immense. So we glorified God, that the angels might know that we are created beings and that He is far removed from our attributes. And the angels glorified God with our glorification and declared Him far removed from our attributes. When they beheld the greatness of our station, we declared 'There is no god but God,' that the angels might know that there is no god but God, and that we are servants and not gods who should be worshipped alongside Him or apart from Him. So they said, 'There is no god but God.' When they beheld the greatness of our rank, we declared 'God is greater,' that the angels might know that God is greater than that the greatness of rank can be attained except through Him. When they beheld the honor and strength God had granted us, we said, 'There is no power and no strength except in God,' that the angels might know that we have no power and no strength except in God. When they beheld what God had bestowed upon us and the obedience He had made obligatory toward us, we said, 'Praise be to God,' that the angels might know what is due to God, exalted be His mention, from us of praise for His blessing. So the angels said, 'Praise be to God.' Thus through us they were guided to the knowledge of God's oneness, His glorification, His declaration of oneness, His praise, and His magnification. Then God, blessed and exalted, created Adam and placed us as a trust within his loins, and He commanded the angels to prostrate to him in veneration of us and honor. Their prostration was worship of God, mighty and majestic, and honor and obedience to Adam because of our being within his loins. So how should we not be more excellent than the angels, when all of them together prostrated to Adam? And when I was taken up to the heaven, Gabriel called the call to prayer in pairs and the standing call in pairs, then said to me, 'Go forward, O Muhammad.' I said to him, 'O Gabriel, shall I go forward before you?' He said, 'Yes, for God, blessed and exalted, has favored His prophets over all His angels, and favored you especially.' So I went forward and led them in prayer, and there is no boasting. When I reached the veils of light, Gabriel said to me, 'Go forward, O Muhammad,' and stayed behind me. I said, 'O Gabriel, in a place like this will you leave me?' He said, 'O Muhammad, the limit of my boundary, which God, mighty and majestic, has set for me, ends at this place. If I were to pass beyond it, my wings would burn for transgressing the bounds of my Lord, majestic is His majesty.' Then He cast me into the light with a casting until I reached where God willed of the height of His dominion. Then I was called, 'O Muhammad.' I said, 'Here I am, my Lord, and at Your service; blessed are You and exalted.' Then I was called, 'O Muhammad, you are My servant and I am your Lord. So worship Me alone and place your trust in Ali, for you are My light among My servants and My messenger to My creation and My proof against My creatures. For you and for those who follow you I created My Paradise, and for those who oppose you I created My Fire. And for your successors I have made My honor obligatory, and for their followers I have made My reward obligatory.' I said, 'O Lord, and who are my successors?' Then I was called, 'O Muhammad, your successors are those inscribed upon the leg of My Throne.' So I looked, while I was before my Lord, majestic is His majesty, at the leg of the Throne, and I saw twelve lights, in each light a green line upon which was the name of a successor from among my successors. The first of them is Ali ibn Abi Talib and the last of them is the Mahdi of my community. I said, 'O Lord, are these my successors after me?' Then I was called, 'O Muhammad, these are My friends, My beloved, My chosen ones, and My proofs after you against My creatures. They are your successors and your vicegerents and the best of My creation after you. By My might and My majesty, I will surely make My religion manifest through them, raise My word through them, purify the earth through the last of them from My enemies, grant him dominion over the east of the earth and its west, subject the winds to him, subdue the difficult clouds to him, raise him through the means, grant him victory with My army, and support him with My angels, until My call prevails and creation gathers upon My oneness. Then I will make his dominion lasting and alternate the days among My friends until the Day of Resurrection.'"
Ilal al-Sharai'; vol. 1, p. 5

Husayn ibn Ali, from his father Ali ibn Abi Talib (peace be upon them), who said: The Messenger of God (peace and blessings be upon him and his family) said:
God, exalted and majestic, has not created any being more excellent or more honored than me.
Ali (peace be upon him) said:
I said: Are you more excellent or Gabriel?
The Prophet said: O Ali, the True One, blessed and exalted, favored the prophets over His angels brought near, and favored me over all the prophets, and excellence after me belongs to you and to the Imams after you. The angels are our servants and the servants of our friends. O Ali, these angels are those who bear the Throne of divine majesty, and those around the Throne are occupied with glorifying and praising the Truth and seek forgiveness from God for those who believe in our guardianship. O Ali, were we not, God would not have created Adam and Eve, would not have brought into being Paradise and Hell, would not have brought forth the heaven and the earth. That being so, how should we not be more excellent than the angels, when we came to know our Lord before them and engaged in His glorification, His declaration of oneness, and His sanctification? For the first being the Lord of the worlds created was our spirits; after creating them, He made them speak of His oneness and His praise. Then He created the angels. When they beheld that our spirits were a single light, they regarded our affair as immense, and we glorified God so that the angels might know that we are creatures of the Majesty and that He is far removed from the attributes of us created beings. The angels, seeing this, likewise engaged in the glorification of the Truth through our glorification and declared Him far removed from our attributes.
And when they beheld the greatness of our station, we declared His oneness so that they might know there is no god besides the Truth—glorious is His majesty—and that we are His servants and not creators. We proclaimed His oneness, declaring every object of worship besides Him to be false. When the angels saw this, they too hastened to say, لا إله إلا الله. And when they witnessed the exaltedness of our rank and station, we proclaimed His greatness, so that they might know that God, the Most High, is greater than all things, and that the greatness of our rank and station is solely through Him.

When they witnessed our honor and strength, we said, لا حول و لا قوه الا بالله, so that they might know that all honor and strength come only through the grace of the Creator.

And when they saw the abundant blessings God had bestowed upon us, and understood that obedience to us was incumbent upon them, we said الحمد لله, so that they might know that in return for these blessings, He deserves to be praised. The angels then followed by saying الحمد لله.

Thus, through us, the angels were guided to affirm the oneness of God and to glorify, proclaim His oneness, praise and exalt Him.

After creating our spirits, God, Blessed and Exalted, created Adam and placed us in his loins as a trust. To honor and revere us, He commanded the angels to prostrate themselves before Adam. In reality, this prostration was worship of God, عز و جل, and an honor to Adam; and since we were in his back and loins, it was obedience to us. How, then, could we not be superior to the angels, when they all prostrated themselves before Adam?

Another proof of our superiority over the angels is that when I was taken up to heaven, Jibril علیه السلام recited the call to prayer and the iqama, two phrases at a time.

Then he said to me, “O Muhammad, step forward.”

I said to him, “You want me to go ahead of you, O Jibril?”

He said, “Yes, for God, the Most High, has given His prophets in general—and you in particular—precedence over all the angels. So go ahead and lead the angels in prayer.”

This was no ordinary honor. I went forward, and when I reached the veils of light, Jibril said, “O Muhammad, go on ahead. I must part from you.”

I said, “O Jibril, will you leave me alone here?”

He replied, “This is the furthest limit God, عز و جل, has set for me. If I go beyond it, my wings will burn.” Then he cast me into the light, and I continued forward through it as far as God willed. Then I heard a voice say, یا محمد.

I replied, “Yes, my Lord.”

The voice said, “O Muhammad, you are My servant, and I am your Lord. Worship Me alone, and place your trust in Me alone. You are a light among My servants, a Messenger to creation, and My proof over all that I have created. I have created My Paradise for you and your followers, and made Hell for those who oppose you. I will grant honor to your successors and reward and recompense to your Shi'a.”

I asked, “My Lord, who are my successors?”

The voice said, “O Muhammad, their names are written on the Pillar of the Throne.” As I stood before my Lord, جل جلاله, I looked at the Pillar of the Throne. I saw twelve lights, each bearing a green inscription with the name of one of my trustees and successors. The first was Ali ibn Abi Talib علیه السلام, and the last was the name of the Mahdi of my community.

I asked, “My Lord, are these the successors who will come after me?”

The voice said, “O Muhammad, they are My governors, My beloved, My chosen ones, and My proofs over humanity after you. They are your successors and the best of My creatures after you. By My might and majesty, through them I will surely make My religion manifest and establish My faith. Through the last of them, I will cleanse the earth of My enemies and give him dominion over the eastern and western regions of the inhabited world. I will subject the winds to him, tame the heavy clouds for him, place the means and instruments at his disposal, aid him with My armies, and support him with My angels, until My call is established across the earth and all creation unites in affirming My oneness. Then he will extend his sovereignty and rule, and time will continue to pass under his reign among My friends until the Day of Resurrection comes.”

علل الشرائع / Zehni Tehrani translation, vol. 1, p. 43

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022