If possible, could you cite a few more hadiths showing that Hajj and tabarri stand on the same footing? And inwardly, is there really no difference between them?
Could you cite hadiths showing that Hajj and tabarri stand on the same footing?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Tawalli and tabarri must always be alive in the heart, but how they are expressed in society depends on the circumstances. In some cases, publicly cursing the enemy may provoke greater resistance or create difficulties for believers, so it should be avoided. This principle is also reflected in Ziyarat Ashura, in the way the curse is expressed.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterCursing has both an individual and a social effect. When making such a curse public might embolden a spiteful enemy, provoke a false show of resistance, intensify their bigotry and ignorant zeal, or create difficulties for believers, it should not be made public.
الأنعام : 108 و لا تسبوا الذین یدعون من دون الله فیسبوا الله عدوا بغیر علم کذلک زینا لکل أمه عملهم ثم إلى ربهم مرجعهم فینبئهم بما کانوا یعملون
Do not revile those whom they invoke besides God, lest they revile God in hostility and out of ignorance. Thus We have made the deeds of every community seem pleasing to them. Then they will return to their Lord, and He will inform them of what they used to do.
عن أبی جعفر ع قال: فی التوراه مکتوب فیما ناجى الله عز و جل به موسى بن عمران ع یا موسى اکتم مکتوم سری فی سریرتک و أظهر فی علانیتک المداراه عنی لعدوی و عدوک من خلقی و لا تستسب لی عندهم بإظهار مکتوم سری فتشرک عدوک و عدوی فی سبی.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج2، ص: 117
Imam al-Baqir (AS) said: It is written in the Torah, in what God, Mighty and Exalted, whispered to Moses son of Amram (AS): “O Moses, keep My hidden secret within yourself, and openly show kindness, for My sake, to those of My creatures who are My enemies and yours. Do not make them revile Me by revealing My hidden secret, lest you join My enemy and yours in reviling Me.”
The beauty of Ziyarat Ashura lies in the way it invokes curses:
اللهم العن أول ظالم ظلم حق محمد و آل محمد [آل محمد حقوقهم] و آخر تابع له على ذلک اللهم العن العصابه التی حاربت [جاهدت] الحسین و شایعت و بایعت [تابعت] أعداءه على قتله
اللهم خص أنت أول ظالم باللعن منی، و ابدأ به أولا ثم الثانی و الثالث و الرابع، اللهم العن یزید خامسا، و العن عبید الله بن زیاد و ابن مرجانه و عمر بن سعد و شمرا، و آل أبی سفیان و آل زیاد و آل مروان إلى یوم القیامه.
Love for God’s friends and rejection of His enemies must always be alive in the heart. How they are expressed in society, however, depends on the circumstances.