#SupplementaryQuestion2513
3. What is the criterion for tawatur, and how is it established?
What Is the Criterion for Tawatur, and How Is It Established?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The criterion for tawatur is that a report yield certainty and assurance, not merely that it be transmitted by a large number of narrators. Tawatur is of three types: verbal, semantic, and aggregate. Reports on a given subject must be numerous enough to yield certainty and make denial impossible for the public at large.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterSecond Page
When reports concerning a particular subject reach a level that produces certainty, certainty about the truth of a report is a matter of both reason and the heart. Once an individual attains this certainty, it is binding proof only for that person. But when a report comes from an individual and is made public in a way that removes the possibility of denial, it becomes a definitive report for the public at large.
We should bear in mind that most reports transmitted by tawātur are semantic or consensus-based.
The criterion for tawātur is that it be conclusive and inspire confidence; it is not simply the large number of transmitters at different levels!
Supplement
Conditions for a report transmitted by tawātur:
1. The number of those reporting must be such that it is inconceivable that they could agree to lie.
2. At every level of the chain, from its beginning to its end, the number of transmitters must be sufficient to establish tawātur.
3. Their report must be based on sensory perception, not on conjecture.
Tawātur is of three kinds:
1. Verbal tawātur
2. Semantic tawātur
3. Overall tawātur
Verbal tawātur refers to a large number of reports that share the same wording and meaning, in sufficient number to produce certainty.
Overall tawātur refers to a large number of reports that differ in wording and meaning, in sufficient number to inspire confidence in the truth of some of them or in the truth of their shared meaning.
Semantic tawātur refers to a large number of reports that share a meaning.