Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2517 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Who became Imam after Abraham, and what does the pronoun “them” refer to in the verse “وجعلناهم ائمة”?

Primary reference: See the answer text 36 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2517

#Follow-up_question2513
سلام علیکم, Professor. A gentleman has raised three questions about the text of Your Eminence’s answer. I am sending them to you so that, ان شاءالله, we can arrive at a suitable response.

Dear Professor, I am imposing on you with these questions, and I am grateful for your help. Please forgive me for troubling you.

I pray that God grants you and your esteemed family a blessed hereafter.
[Forwarded from Saeed Hasan-Zadeh Delgosha]
1. Who became Imam after Abraham?
2. What does the pronoun “هم” in the verse “وجعلناهم ائمه” refer to?
3. What is the criterion for tawātur, and how is it established?

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

After Abraham (AS), Joseph, Moses, David, Solomon, the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), and then the Infallible Imams (AS) were the Imams of their respective times. The pronoun “هم” in the verse “وجعلناهم ائمة” may refer either to the righteous prophets or to the descendants of Abraham (AS), who inherited the imamate from generation to generation.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

First Page

It may not be possible to name with complete precision all the great prophets who held the Imamate after Abraham, peace be upon him. But certainly Joseph, peace be upon him, Moses, peace be upon him, David, peace be upon him, Solomon, peace be upon him, and others, as well as Muhammad, peace and blessings be upon him and his family, and, after him, the Infallible Imams, peace be upon them—from the Commander of the Faithful, peace be upon him, to the Imam of the Age, the Mahdi—were and are the Imams of their respective times.

In light of the preceding verses, the pronoun may also refer to the righteous prophets or to the righteous descendants of Abraham!

فلم تزل فی ذریته یرثها بعض عن بعض قرنا فقرنا حتى ورثها الله تعالى النبی ص فقال جل و تعالى‏
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج‏1، ص: 199

**An Elaboration of the Subject**

ʿAbd al-ʿAzīz ibn Muslim relates: We were in Marw during the days of Ḥaḍrat Riḍā. Shortly after our arrival, on a Friday, we gathered in the congregational mosque. Those present began discussing the question of the Imamate and recounting how deeply people differed about it. I went to my master and told him what people had been saying about the Imamate. Ḥaḍrat (AS) smiled and said:

“O ʿAbd al-ʿAzīz, these people have failed to understand. They have been deceived by their own opinions and led astray. God, عز و جل, did not take the soul of His Prophet until He had perfected the religion for him and sent down the Qur’an to him, in which all things are made clear: the lawful and the forbidden, the limits and the rulings, and everything people need. He said, ‘We have left nothing out of this Book’ (6:38).

“During the Farewell Pilgrimage, in the final year of the Prophet’s life (PBUH), He revealed this verse: ‘Today I have perfected your religion for you, completed My favor upon you, and chosen Islam as your religion’ (5:3). The question of the Imamate is part of the perfection of religion. (Until the Prophet (PBUH) had named his successor, he had not completed his mission.) The Prophet (PBUH) did not depart this world until he had explained the signs of the religion to his community, shown them their way, set them upon the straight path of truth, and appointed ʿAlī as their leader and Imam. He had explained everything the community needed. So whoever supposes that God, عز و جل, did not perfect His religion has rejected the Qur’an; and whoever rejects the Qur’an is an unbeliever.

“Do people even know the rank and station of the Imamate among the community, that it should be entrusted to their choice and election? The Imamate is too exalted in worth, too great in significance, too lofty in rank, too inaccessible in station, and too profound in depth for people to attain it through their own reason, comprehend it through their opinions, or appoint an Imam by their own choice.

“The Imamate is a station that God, عز و جل, bestowed upon Abraham, His intimate friend, as a third distinction, after prophethood and intimate friendship. He honored him with it and raised his name. He said, ‘I am making you an Imam for the people’ (2:124). In his great joy, Abraham, His intimate friend, asked, ‘And among my descendants?’ God, تبارك و تعالى, replied, ‘My covenant does not extend to the wrongdoers.’ Thus this verse declared the Imamate forbidden to wrongdoers until the Day of Resurrection, and confined it to the chosen. Then God Most High further honored Abraham by placing the Imamate among his chosen and pure descendants. He said, ‘And We bestowed upon him Isaac and Jacob as an additional gift, and made them all righteous. We made them leaders, guiding by Our command, and revealed to them the doing of good works, the establishment of prayer, and the giving of zakat. They were devoted worshippers of Us’ (21:72).

“So the Imamate remained among his descendants, passing from one generation to another as an inheritance, until God Most High bestowed it as an inheritance upon our Prophet (PBUH). He Himself, جل و تعالى, said, ‘Indeed, those with the strongest claim to Abraham are those who followed him, this Prophet, and the believers; and God is the protector of the believers’ (3:68). Thus the Imamate became the Prophet’s exclusive right, and by God Most High’s command, in accordance with what God had ordained, he entrusted it to ʿAlī. Thereafter it passed among his chosen descendants, whom God had given knowledge and faith. God has said, ‘Those who were given knowledge and faith will say, “You remained, according to the Book of God, until the Day of Resurrection”’ (30:56).

“Therefore the Imamate belongs exclusively to the descendants of ʿAlī until the Day of Resurrection, for there is no prophet after Muḥammad (PBUH). Where do these ignorant people get the idea, and on what grounds, that they can choose an Imam for themselves? The Imamate is the station of the prophets and the inheritance of their successors. It is the vicegerency of God and the vicegerency of the Messenger of God (PBUH); it is the station of the Commander of the Faithful (AS), and the inheritance of Ḥasan and Ḥusayn علیهما السلام.

“The Imamate is the reins of religion, the means by which Muslims are kept in order, the well-being of this world, and the honor of the believers. It is the growing root of Islam and its lofty branch. The Imam makes prayer, zakat, fasting, pilgrimage, and jihad complete; through him spoils and charitable alms increase, the limits and rulings are enforced, and the frontiers and borders are protected. It is the Imam who makes what God has made lawful lawful, and what He has forbidden forbidden; who upholds God’s limits, defends His religion, and calls people to the way of his Lord with wisdom, good counsel, and a compelling proof.

“The Imam is like the rising sun, whose light encompasses the world while he himself remains on the horizon, beyond the reach of hands and eyes. The Imam is the shining moon, the radiant lamp, the brilliant light, and the guiding star in the deepest darkness, guiding travelers through cities, deserts, and the whirlpools of the sea—that is, through times of ignorance, turmoil, and people’s bewilderment. The Imam is fresh water in a time of thirst, a guide to right guidance, and a rescuer from ruin. The Imam is a fire burning atop a hill, a beacon for the lost, a source of warmth for those stricken by cold, and a guide through places of peril. Whoever parts from him perishes.” The Imam is a rain-bearing cloud, a driving rain, a radiant sun, a sheltering canopy, a spread-out earth, a gushing spring, a pool and a garden. The Imam is a companion and friend, a kind father, an equal brother, a mother tender toward her child, and a refuge for God’s servants in times of great hardship. The Imam is God’s trustee among His creation, His proof over His servants, His vicegerent in His lands, one who calls people to Him and defends His rights. The Imam is free of sin and untouched by flaw, distinguished by knowledge and marked by forbearance. He is the source of order in religion and dignity for Muslims, the cause of the hypocrites’ anger and the unbelievers’ ruin. The Imam is unique in his time; no one can attain his rank, no scholar can equal him, and he has no successor. He has neither likeness nor counterpart. Every virtue is his alone, though he has neither sought nor acquired it for himself; rather, it is a distinction that God has bestowed upon him through His grace and generosity....

أبو محمد القاسم بن العلاء رحمه الله رفعه عن عبد العزیز بن مسلم قال: کنا مع الرضا ع بمرو فاجتمعنا فی الجامع یوم الجمعه فی بدء مقدمنا فأداروا أمر الإمامه و ذکروا کثره اختلاف الناس فیها فدخلت على سیدی ع فأعلمته خوض الناس فیه فتبسم ع ثم قال یا عبد العزیز جهل القوم و خدعوا عن آرائهم إن الله عز و جل لم یقبض نبیه ص حتى أکمل له الدین و أنزل علیه القرآن فیه تبیان کل شی‏ء بین فیه الحلال و الحرام و الحدود و الأحکام و جمیع ما یحتاج إلیه الناس کملا فقال عز و جل- ما فرطنا فی الکتاب من شی‏ء «1» و أنزل فی حجه الوداع و هی آخر عمره ص الیوم أکملت لکم دینکم و أتممت علیکم نعمتی و رضیت لکم الإسلام دینا «2» و أمر الإمامه من تمام الدین و لم یمض ص حتى بین لأمته معالم دینهم و أوضح لهم سبیلهم و ترکهم على قصد سبیل الحق و أقام لهم علیا ع علما و إماما و ما ترک لهم شیئا یحتاج إلیه الأمه إلا بینه فمن زعم أن الله عز و جل لم یکمل دینه فقد رد کتاب الله و من رد کتاب الله فهو کافر به هل یعرفون قدر الإمامه و محلها من الأمه فیجوز فیها اختیارهم إن الإمامه أجل قدرا و أعظم شأنا و أعلى مکانا و أمنع جانبا و أبعد غورا من أن یبلغها الناس بعقولهم أو ینالوها بآرائهم أو یقیموا إماما باختیارهم إن الإمامه خص الله عز و جل بها إبراهیم الخلیل ع بعد النبوه و الخله مرتبه ثالثه و فضیله شرفه بها و أشاد بها ذکره «3» فقال إنی جاعلک للناس إماما «4» فقال الخلیل ع سرورا بها- و من ذریتی قال الله تبارک و تعالى- لا ینال عهدی الظالمین فأبطلت هذه الآیه إمامه کل ظالم إلى یوم القیامه و صارت فی الصفوه ثم أکرمه الله تعالى بأن جعلها فی ذریته أهل الصفوه و الطهاره فقال و وهبنا له إسحاق و یعقوب نافله و کلا جعلنا صالحین. و جعلناهم أئمه یهدون بأمرنا و أوحینا إلیهم فعل الخیرات و إقام الصلاه و إیتاء الزکاه و کانوا لنا عابدین «5» فلم تزل فی ذریته یرثها بعض عن بعض قرنا فقرنا حتى ورثها الله تعالى النبی ص فقال جل و تعالى- إن أولى الناس بإبراهیم للذین اتبعوه و هذا النبی و الذین آمنوا و الله ولی المؤمنین «6» فکانت له خاصه فقلدها ص علیا ع‏

بأمر الله تعالى على رسم ما فرض الله فصارت فی ذریته الأصفیاء الذین آتاهم الله العلم و الإیمان بقوله تعالى- و قال الذین أوتوا العلم و الإیمان لقد لبثتم فی کتاب الله إلى‏ یوم البعث «1» فهی فی ولد علی ع خاصه إلى یوم القیامه إذ لا نبی بعد محمد ص فمن أین یختار هؤلاء الجهال إن الإمامه هی منزله الأنبیاء و إرث الأوصیاء إن الإمامه خلافه الله و خلافه الرسول ص و مقام أمیر المؤمنین ع و میراث الحسن و الحسین ع إن الإمامه زمام الدین و نظام المسلمین و صلاح الدنیا و عز المؤمنین إن الإمامه أس الإسلام النامی و فرعه السامی بالإمام تمام الصلاه و الزکاه و الصیام و الحج و الجهاد و توفیر الفی‏ء و الصدقات و إمضاء الحدود و الأحکام و منع الثغور و الأطراف الإمام یحل حلال الله و یحرم حرام الله و یقیم حدود الله و یذب عن دین الله و یدعو إلى سبیل ربه بالحکمه و الموعظه الحسنه و الحجه البالغه الإمام کالشمس الطالعه المجلله بنورها للعالم و هی فی الأفق بحیث لا تنالها الأیدی و الأبصار الإمام البدر المنیر و السراج الزاهر و النور الساطع و النجم الهادی فی غیاهب الدجى «2» و أجواز البلدان و القفار و لجج البحار الإمام الماء العذب على الظمإ و الدال على الهدى و المنجی من الردى الإمام النار على الیفاع «3» الحار لمن اصطلى به و الدلیل فی المهالک من فارقه فهالک الإمام السحاب الماطر و الغیث الهاطل «4» و الشمس المضیئه و السماء الظلیله و الأرض البسیطه...
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج‏1، ص: 198

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022