Ustadh, please share your opinion on this text: “The Qur’an contains nothing but good, so the istikhara performed by these gentlemen is also set aside” (that is, performing istikhara was wrong). … Can you touch the word *kalb* (dog) without wudu? Even if you see words in the Qur’an such as dog, unbeliever, polytheist, hypocrite, wine, and the like, you must not touch them without wudu ... Now, with this reasoning, would they allow us to touch the body of an unbeliever who exists in the outside world without wudu? They say: ‘No, you must still have wudu.’ And then suddenly you see: God is being God ...
What is the scholar’s opinion of the text in question?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Istikhara means seeking God’s help to be guided toward what is best, and all the verses of the Qur’an are light and illumination. Although words such as dog, Satan, hypocrite, and polytheist occur in the Qur’an, these words are distinct from what they denote, and the impurity of their referents remains; therefore, one should not touch them without wudu. Light reveals the truth without becoming tainted itself.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterIstikhara means that the person seeking guidance turns to God, the All-Knowing, for help, asking Him to inspire the heart with what is good. It does not mean asking the All-Knowing Lord to distinguish the verses that are good from those that are evil. Every verse of the Quran is light and illumination; there is no doubt about that.
The Creator of the universe has no likeness or affinity with His creation. Nothing resembles Him!
All of God’s creatures are divine signs. Insofar as they are connected to the Beautiful Creator, they are beautiful; but considered in themselves, they are distinguished as good or bad.
An-Nisa: 79
ما أصابک من حسنه فمن الله و ما أصابک من سیئه فمن نفسک و أرسلناک للناس رسولا و کفى بالله شهیدا
“Whatever good comes to you is from God, and whatever ill befalls you is from yourself. We have sent you as a Messenger to humanity, and God is sufficient as a witness to this.”
All creatures are divine signs, but those creatures that have preserved their inherent goodness are the most beautiful signs of God.
Words such as “dog,” “Satan,” “Abu Lahab,” “hypocrite,” “polytheist,” and “disbeliever,” though they occur among the verses of the Quran, are not the same as the things they denote, and do nothing to lessen the impurity of those beings. It is like light shining on filth and reflecting its image into the eye: the light and the image are pure and wholesome, but the filth remains filthy. The reflected light is, in effect, a glimmer of knowledge that tells us about something pure or impure. The divine signs, too, are light and illumination that impart awareness.
An-Nisa: 174
یا أیها الناس قد جاءکم برهان من ربکم و أنزلنا إلیکم نورا مبینا
“O people, a clear proof has come to you from your Lord, and We have sent down to you a manifest light.”
At-Tawba: 28
یا أیها الذین آمنوا إنما المشرکون نجس ...
“O you who believe, the polytheists are impure ...”
If a person’s hand touches something impure, it becomes impure!
An-Nisa: 43
یا أیها الذین آمنوا لا تقربوا الصلاه و أنتم سکارى حتى تعلموا ما تقولون و لا جنبا إلا عابری سبیل حتى تغتسلوا و إن کنتم مرضى أو على سفر أو جاء أحد منکم من الغائط أو لامستم النساء فلم تجدوا ماء فتیمموا صعیدا طیبا فامسحوا بوجوهکم و أیدیکم إن الله کان عفوا غفورا
“O you who believe, do not approach the prayer while you are intoxicated, until you know what you are saying; nor while in a state of major ritual impurity—unless you are travelling—until you have bathed. If you are ill or travelling, or one of you has relieved himself, or you have been intimate with women, and you find no water, then seek clean earth and wipe your faces and hands with it. God is Pardoning and Forgiving.”
The author of the article seems to have conflated knowledge with what is known! Light reveals the truth; it brings out beauty and makes flaws and impurities visible, without itself becoming tainted by impurity!
By the end of the article, all sense of propriety has collapsed, and the author has poured out everything born of his ignorance. What a profound lack of understanding!
An-Nahl: 60
للذین لا یؤمنون بالآخره مثل السوء و لله المثل الأعلى و هو العزیز الحکیم
Ar-Rum: 27
و هو الذی یبدؤا الخلق ثم یعیده و هو أهون علیه و له المثل الأعلى فی السماوات و الأرض و هو العزیز الحکیم
“For those who do not believe in the Hereafter are attributes of evil, while God has the highest attributes. He is the Almighty, the Wise.” (60)
“He is the One who originates creation and then brings it back again; that is easier for Him. His is the highest attribute in the heavens and the earth. He is the Almighty, the Wise.” (27)