Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2012 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

What Is the Teacher’s View of Dr Majdi’s Research on Word Counts in the Qur’an?

Primary reference: See the answer text 100 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2012

Dr. Majdi, an Egyptian national, used the Quran to demonstrate the number of Shia Imams. Dr. Majdi Wahba al-Shafi‘i, a preacher and professor at the religious university of al-Azhar, made some remarkable discoveries through his research, astonishing everyone. In the wake of these findings, he embraced Shi‘ism.

Consider this:

The numbers and figures in the Quran are not without purpose; they serve particular ends. For example, the word یوم (day) occurs 365 times, corresponding to the number of days in a year. The word شهر (month) appears 12 times in the Quran, corresponding to the number of months in a year. There are many other examples.

Taking these facts into account, he conducted research in this area and reached the following remarkable conclusions:

The word امام occurs twelve times, matching the number of Shia Imams.

The word امام appears in these verses:
البقره 124 التوبه 12 هود 17 الاسراء 70 الانبیاء 72 القصص 5 الحجر 79 السجده 24 یس 12 القصص 41 الفرقان 74 الأحقاف 12

The word شیعه, or one of its derivatives, occurs 12 times in the Quran.

The word العصمه (infallibility)—which Shias believe belongs to the 12 Imams (AS), Fatima al-Zahra (SA), and the Prophet Muhammad Mustafa (PBUH)—is repeated 14 times in the Quran.

In these verses:
النساء 146 آل عمران 101 النساء 175 المائده 67 آل عمران 103 یوسف 32 یونس 27 هود (دو کلمه در این آیه) 43 الأحزاب 17 غافر 33 الممتحنه 10 الحج 78

The word الکساء (that is, آل عبا), in all its forms, appears five times in the Noble Quran. According to a report from أم سلمه in the Sunni collections known as صحیحین, the Prophet’s wife said that they numbered five: the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), Imam Ali, Fatima al-Zahra, Hasan, and Husayn (peace be upon them all):

البقره 233
البقره 259
المائده 89
المؤمنون 14
النساء 5

We should be proud to be Twelver Shias. No one, at any time, will be able to undermine or destroy this true school of thought.

Why were there twelve springs from which the Prophet Moses provided water for his people?

And why are there twelve months (شهر) in the Quran?

There are also 12 tribes, الأسباط; 12 leaders, النقباء; 12 zodiac signs, البروج; and 12 disciples, الحواریین. The expression of divine oneness ( لا اله إلا الله ) has 12 letters, as do ( محمد رسول الله ), ( النبی المصطفى ), and ( الصادق الأمین ). Surely the Imams of the Prophet’s Household are twelve. ( أمیر المؤمنین ) has 12 letters, as do ( فاطمه الزهراء ), ( الحسن والحسین ), ( الحسن المجتبى ), ( الحسین الشهید ), ( الإمام السجاد ), ( الإمام الباقر ), ( الإمام الصادق ), ( الإمام الکاظم ), ( الإمام الرضاء ), ( الإمام الجواد ), ( الإمام الهادى ), ( الحسن العسکرى ), ( القائم المهدى ), ( خلیفه النبیین ), ( و خاتم الوصیین ), ( و هؤلاء العتره ), ( ساده أهل الجنه), ( محبهم مؤمن تقى ), and ( عدوهم کافر شقى ).

Now consider the wonder of the verse of purification:

( إنما یرید الله لیذهب عنکم الرجس أهل البیت و یطهرکم تطهیرا )

This verse contains 47 letters. The number of letters in the following names is:

فاطمه 5 على 3 حسن 3 حسین 4 على 3 محمد 4 جعفر 4 موسى 4 على 3 محمد 4 على 3 حسن 3 محمد 4

Altogether, 47 letters.

Professor, what is your view on this?

#Answer2102

We Shias believe that the Quran and the Prophet’s Household are like two mirrors facing one another, and that it is impossible to separate them.

We believe that the Prophet’s Household is the spirit and speaking voice of the Quran, and that many Quranic verses, through their wording, allusion, subtlety, and truth, affirm the standing of these revered figures.

We also know that the Quran’s inner depths hold hidden mysteries concerning these revered figures. We further believe that the number of words, their repetition and derivatives, and their letters and numerical values conceal many secrets within them.

However, using the repetition of certain words as evidence to establish the status of these revered figures weakens the force of our language and sound arguments. We must therefore be very cautious when presenting arguments of this kind, since an opponent could take issue by citing certain derivatives and forms of words, and thereby accuse the Shia.

There are so many clear proofs establishing the greatness of wilayah and the Imamate that we have no need to resort to arguments of this kind.

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Great caution is needed when using arguments based on the repetition of words and numbers in the Qur’an to establish the truth of Shiism, since they may be challenged by citing other derivatives and forms of those words. There are clearer and stronger proofs of the greatness of wilayah and the Imamate, making such arguments unnecessary.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

Question 2012:

🔴 Dr Majdi, an Egyptian national, used the Quran to establish the number of Shia Imams. Dr Majdi Wahba al-Shafi‘i, a preacher and lecturer at the religious university of al-Azhar, made some remarkable discoveries through his research, astonishing everyone. He subsequently embraced Shia Islam.

📢 Please note 📢

🔵 Since numbers in the Quran are not without reason and serve a particular purpose—for example, the word “day” (يوم) occurs 365 times, the number of days in a year, while the word “month” (شهر) appears 12 times, the number of months in a year—and there are many other examples…

🔻Drawing on this information, he conducted research on the subject and arrived at these remarkable findings:

✅ The word “Imam” occurs twelve times, corresponding to the number of Shia Imams.

The word Imam appears in these verses:
🍁البقره ۱۲۴ 🍁التوبه ۱۲ 🍁هود ۱۷ 🍁الاسراء ۷۰ 🍁الانبياء ۷۲ 🍁القصص ۵ 🍁الحجر ۷۹ 🍁السجدة ۲۴ 🍁يس ۱۲ 🍁القصص ۴۱ 🍁الفرقان ۷۴ 🍁الأحقاف ۱۲

✅ The word “Shia” and its derivatives occur 12 times in the Quran.

✅ The word العصمه (infallibility), which the Shia believe applies to the 12 Imams (AS), Fatima al-Zahra (SA), and the Prophet Muhammad Mustafa (PBUH), occurs 14 times in the Quran.

🔻In these verses:
🍃النساء ۱۴۶ 🍃آل عمران ۱۰۱ 🍃النساء ۱۷۵ 🍃المائدة ۶۷ 🍃آل عمران ۱۰۳ 🍃يوسف ۳۲ 🍃يونس ۲۷ 🍃هود (دو کلمه در این آیه) ۴۳ 🍃الأحزاب ۱۷ 🍃غافر ۳۳ 🍃الممتحنة ۱۰ 🍃الحج ۷۸

✅ The word الكساء (or آل عبا), in all its forms, appears five times in the Holy Quran. According to a report from Umm Salama in the Sunni books (the Sahihayn), the Prophet’s wife, they were five: the Prophet Muhammad (PBUH), Imam Ali, Fatima al-Zahra, Hasan, and Husayn (peace be upon them all). It appears in the Quran in these five places:

البقرة ۲۳۳
البقرة ۲۵۹
المائدة ۸۹
المؤمنون ۱۴
النساء ۵

👌 We should be proud to be Twelver Shia, and no one, at any time, will be able to undermine or destroy this true school of thought.

✅ Why were there 12 springs from which the Prophet Moses provided water for his people?

✅ And likewise, the 12 months (شهر) in the Quran; the 12 tribes (الأسباط), 12 chiefs (النقباء), 12 zodiac signs (البروج), 12 disciples (الحواريين); the phrase of divine unity ( لا اله إلا الله ) has 12 letters, and ( محمد رسول الله ) has 12 letters, and ( النبي المصطفى ) has 12 letters, and ( الصادق الأمين ) has 12 letters. Indeed, the Imams of the Ahl al-Bayt are 12 Imams. And ( أمير المؤمنين ) has 12 letters, and ( فاطمة الزهراء ) has 12 letters, and ( الحسن والحسين ) has 12 letters, and ( الحسن المجتبى ) has 12 letters, and ( الحسين الشهيد ) has 12 letters, and ( الإمام السجاد ) has 12 letters, and ( الإمام الباقر ) has 12 letters, and ( الإمام الصادق ) has 12 letters, and ( الإمام الكاظم ) has 12 letters, and ( الإمام الرضاء ) has 12 letters, and ( الإمام الجواد ) has 12 letters, and ( الإمام الهادى ) has 12 letters, and ( الحسن العسكرى ) has 12 letters, and ( القائم المهدى ) has 12 letters, and ( خليفة النبيين ) has 12 letters, and ( و خاتم الوصيين ) has 12 letters, and ( و هؤلاء العترة ) has 12 letters, and ( سادة أهل الجنة) has 12 letters, and ( محبهم مؤمن تقى ) has 12 letters, and ( عدوهم كافر شقى ) has 12 letters.

✅ Now let us consider the remarkable verse of purification:

( إنما يريد الله ليذهب عنكم الرجس أهل البيت و يطهركم تطهيرا )

This verse has 47 letters. The names below contain this many letters:

فاطمة ۵ 🌹 على ۳ 🌹 حسن ۳ 🌹 حسين ۴ 🌹 على ۳ 🌹 محمد ۴ 🌹 جعفر ۴ 🌹 موسى ۴ 🌹 على ۳ 🌹 محمد ۴ 🌹 على ۳ 🌹حسن ۳ 🌹 محمد ۴

Altogether, 47 letters.

Teacher, what is your opinion on this?

🌸🔆🌷بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم🌷🔆🌸
#Answer2102

🍀🔅🌷علیکم السلام🌷🔅🍀

🌷🔅🌱We Shia believe that the Quran and the Ahl al-Bayt are two mirrors facing one another, and that it is impossible to separate them.

🌷🔅🌱We believe that the Ahl al-Bayt are the spirit and eloquent voice of the Quran. Many Quranic verses, through their wording, allusions, subtle meanings, and deeper truths, also affirm the station of these revered figures!

🌷🔅🌱We also know that the Quran holds mysteries concerning these revered figures, and we believe that its words, repetitions, derivatives, numbers, and letters contain many hidden secrets.

🌷🔅🌱However, since arguing for the station of these revered figures by citing repetitions of certain words could weaken our clear language and firm proofs in establishing their rightful claim, we should be very cautious in presenting arguments of this kind. An opponent could cite certain derivatives and forms of words to start a dispute and accuse the Shia.

🌸 There are so many clear proofs establishing the greatness of wilayah and the Imamate that we have no need to resort to arguments of this kind.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022