Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 1926 20 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Advanced

Why Did Shaykh al-Saduq Hold That the Prophet Had a Lapse in Prayer?

Primary reference: See the answer text 46 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

The Prophet’s lapse in prayer occurred by God’s will and was a mercy to the community, so that people would not be blamed if they forgot or missed a prayer. This lapse does not call his infallibility into question, for the Prophet acts in accordance with his Lord’s will. It was the most sacred of lapses, willed by the Creator.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

The view attributed to Shaykh al-Saduq regarding the Prophet’s forgetfulness is among the greatest errors into which someone of Shaykh al-Saduq’s stature could fall, because it suggests that he rushed past the deeper meaning of the hadith on which he based his conclusion and failed to examine it with the necessary care.

Please read the hadith in question with the utmost attention and reflection:

قال سمعت أبا عبد الله ع یقول إن الله تبارک و تعالى أنام رسوله ص- عن صلاه الفجر حتى طلعت الشمس ثم قام فبدأ فصلى الرکعتین اللتین قبل الفجر ثم صلى الفجر و أسهاه فی صلاته فسلم فی رکعتین ثم وصف ما قاله ذو الشمالین و إنما فعل ذلک به رحمه لهذه الأمه لئلا یعیر الرجل المسلم إذا هو نام عن صلاته أو سها فیها فیقال قد أصاب ذلک رسول الله ص .

Hasan ibn Mahbub narrates from Ali ibn Hasan ibn Rabat, and he from Sa'id al-A'raj, who said: I heard Imam al-Sadiq, peace be upon him, say:

God, Blessed and Exalted is He, caused His Messenger, peace and blessings be upon him and his family, to sleep, or caused sleep to overcome him, so that the time of the dawn prayer passed and the sun rose. The Prophet then awoke and first performed the two-rak'ah dawn prayer that is offered before the obligatory dawn prayer, after which he performed the dawn prayer. On another occasion, God, Exalted is He, caused him to become forgetful during a four-rak'ah prayer, and he concluded the prayer with the salutation after the second rak'ah. The Imam then recounted the incident involving Dhu al-Shimalayn. God brought about these two occurrences in relation to the Prophet only out of mercy and compassion for this community, lest a Muslim be reproached if sleep overcame him and he missed his prayer, or if he became forgetful during it, and people should say, “This happened even to the Messenger of God, peace and blessings be upon him and his family; therefore, it is understandable if we too experience forgetfulness or sleep.”

Blameworthy forgetfulness is forgetfulness that occurs through a person’s own agency, without any external cause or intervention affecting the one who forgets. Of course, if the self or Satan is the cause of such forgetfulness, it is blameworthy. Even forgetfulness arising from weakness, although it may not itself be blameworthy, is a sign of error; in the case of the prophets, it would indicate the limited nature of their protection from error.

But now, consider the hadith in question.

God, Blessed and Exalted is He, Himself willed it and caused His Prophet to sleep. Let this be noted carefully, very carefully: the Almighty and Incomparable God willed that His prophet should fall asleep!

إن الله تبارک و تعالى أنام رسوله

And God likewise willed that His Prophet should become forgetful during the prayer:

أسهاه فی صلاته

Thus, what took place was precisely what the Creator had willed. Is the Messenger of God not God’s servant?! A servant of God submits to the will of his Lord. This sleep and this forgetfulness were the most sacred of sleep and forgetfulness, for through this will the Creator established one of His own laws. In no way does this call the Messenger of God’s infallibility into question, because even in the matter of infallibility, the Prophet is protected from error by the will of his Lord. God wills that he not err, and the Noble Prophet is protected from error. The Imam goes on to describe this act of God as His grace and mercy:

و إنما فعل ذلک به رحمه لهذه الأمه

It is therefore clear that blameworthy forgetfulness has meaning only when a person, despite the abilities bestowed upon him by the Creator, commits an error because of mental sluggishness or the interference of the self and Satan.

Did the Companions of the Cave, who fell asleep by the will of their Lord, experience blameworthy, erroneous forgetfulness?!

And yet this is the hasty conclusion reached by Shaykh al-Saduq!

The author of this book, may God have mercy on him, says: The extremists and the delegators, may God curse them, deny that the Prophet, peace be upon him and his family, could lapse into forgetfulness. They argue: “If it were possible for the Prophet, peace be upon him and his family, to forget something in prayer, it would also be possible for him to forget something in conveying the religious law, since prayer is an obligation for him just as conveying it is an obligation.” This argument does not compel us to accept that conclusion. For in all the circumstances shared by the Prophet and other people, whatever happens to others can happen to him. He is commanded to pray, as are those who are not prophets. Not everyone other than him is a prophet like him. The state unique to him is prophethood, and conveying the message is one of its conditions. What may happen to him in prayer cannot happen to him in conveying the message , because conveying it is a particular act of worship, whereas prayer is an act of worship shared by all. Through it his servitude to God is made manifest. And by establishing that sleep can overcome him, keeping him from serving his Lord, mighty and exalted, without his will or intention, his divinity is denied. For the one whom sleep, drowsiness, or a nap never overtakes is God alone, the Living, the Self-Subsisting.

The compiler of this book, may God have mercy on him, says: The extremists and the delegators, may God banish them from His mercy, do not accept that the Messenger of God, peace be upon him and his family, could lapse into forgetfulness. They maintain: “If it is possible for the Prophet of God, peace be upon him and his family, to forget in prayer, where one is meant to be fully attentive, then he might also forget while conveying God’s rulings, since prayer is as obligatory for him as conveying God’s rulings is.” …This argument does not convince or bind us to conclude that it must be so. There is no doubt that all shared circumstances—that is, things in which prophets and their successors share with other people, such as eating, drinking, sleeping, and the like—can befall him just as they befall the community. He was also commanded to pray, just as others who were not prophets were commanded to pray. Other people were not prophets like him. Therefore, since lapses of memory can occur in everyone besides him, their occurring in him as well would not conflict with his prophethood. The state unique to him is his mission, and conveying the message is among the conditions and requirements of prophethood and messengership. It is not permissible for him to lapse into forgetfulness while conveying the message, because that is an act of worship specific to the Prophet, whereas prayer is an act of worship shared by all. Through prayer, his servitude is made manifest. And by affirming that sleep can overcome him, leaving him—without his own will or desire—unable to serve God, mighty and exalted, it becomes clear that he is not God. For only God, the Living, the Self-Subsisting, is never overcome by sleep or drowsiness. Of course, the Messenger of God’s lapses of memory, peace be upon him and his family, are not like ours, for his forgetfulness comes from God, mighty and exalted.

God Most High causes him to forget only so that it may be clear that he is a human being, created like other human beings, and that he is distinct from God, the Sustainer …

*Man lā yaḥḍuruhu al-faqīh*, translated by Ali Akbar Ghaffari, Mohammad Javad, and Sadr Balaghi, vol. 1, p. 557.

The mistake al-Saduq made is that he forgot the Prophet had attained a station at which all his actions, words, and states are under the direct control of the Divine! This sleep and forgetfulness, too, are of that same order!

النجم : 3 و ما ینطق عن الهوى‏

He does not speak from his own desire!

النجم : 4 إن هو إلا وحی یوحى‏

What he says is nothing but revelation revealed to him!

الأنفال : 17 ... و ما رمیت إذ رمیت و لکن الله رمى‏ و لیبلی المؤمنین منه بلاء حسنا إن الله سمیع علیم

…It was not you who threw when you threw, but God who threw, so that He might test the believers with a good trial. God is All-Hearing, All-Knowing.

More striking still, the transmitter of the great Ziyarat al-Jami‘a al-Kabira is Shaykh al-Saduq himself, may God have mercy on him! This visitation is a testament to the station of the Infallible Ones, peace be upon them. It describes for them stations that leave the world in awe!

A few passages from Ziyarat al-Jami‘a al-Kabira:

عصمکم الله من الزلل و آمنکم من الفتن و طهرکم من الدنس و أذهب عنکم الرجس أهل البیت‏

و من اعتصم بکم فقد اعتصم بالله

یا ولی الله إن بینی و بین الله عز و جل ذنوبا لا یأتی علیها إلا رضاکم- فبحق من ائتمنکم على سره و استرعاکم أمر خلقه و قرن طاعتکم بطاعته لما استوهبتم ذنوبی و کنتم شفعائی‏ فإنی لکم مطیع من أطاعکم فقد أطاع الله و من عصاکم فقد عصى الله و من أحبکم فقد أحب الله و من أبغضکم فقد أبغض الله اللهم إنی لو وجدت شفعاء أقرب إلیک من محمد و أهل بیته الأخیار- الأئمه الأبرار لجعلتهم شفعائی فبحقهم الذی أوجبت لهم علیک أسألک أن تدخلنی فی جمله العارفین بهم و بحقهم و فی زمره المرحومین بشفاعتهم إنک أرحم الراحمین و صلى الله على محمد و آله و سلم تسلیما کثیرا و حسبنا الله و نعم الوکیل.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022