Please explain the theory that a rational argument shows infallibility is not absolute.
An infallible person is a created being, and created beings are limited; therefore, their attributes are also limited, including the attribute of infallibility.
What Is the Rational Argument for Denying the Absoluteness of Infallibility?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The infallibility of an infallible person should not be understood as unlimited. Rather, a created being is infallible within the bounds of its nature and by God’s will, not independently. Almighty God creates a being from whom no error issues.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe infallibility of the Infallible does not mean that they are unlimited!
A finite creature possesses infallibility within the limits of its own being, by the will of God Most High. The infallibility of the Infallible does not arise from their own independence; rather, it is granted through the power and eternal will of the one, peerless Lord. In His omnipotence, God creates a being from whom no error ever proceeds—a being of consummate beauty, utterly pure, like the Divine Names of Beauty, each perfect in its own sanctity!
A flower of perfect delicacy, a light untouched by darkness, and water of the utmost purity and clarity—all are creatures of God, and the All-Powerful is capable of creating a pure being.
تقدست أسماؤک