Hello, teacher. Sorry to trouble you. How can we reconcile this answer with hadiths that explicitly describe animals as devoid of reason? عن عبدالله ابن سنان قال: سألت اباعبدالله جعفر بن محمد الصادق علیه السلام: فقلت الملائکه افضل ام بنوآدم فقال علیه السلام قال امیرالمؤمنین علی بن ابیطالب علیه السلام ان الله عزوجل رکب فی الملائکه عقلا بلا شهوه و رکب فی البهائم شهوه بلا عقل و رکب فی بنی آدم کلتیهما فمن غلب عقله شهوته فهو خیرمن الملائکه و من غلب شهوته عقله فهو شرمن البهائم /Bihār al-anwār, vol. 60, chapter 39, hadith 5, p. 299
Are Animals Devoid of Reason?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Animals are not devoid of reason; rather, reason manifests in them to varying degrees, and unless it reaches a certain level, a creature is not described as “rational.” Nor does the dominance of desire over a human being mean that reason has vanished altogether: thought remains possible.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe manifestation of reason in the souls of created beings has different degrees. When reason reaches a certain level, a being is called rational. In other words, although beings—including human beings—possess reason, they are not rational unless it has become sufficiently manifest; yet this does not mean they are without reason. For example, when desire overpowers a person, reason departs from them—but this does not mean that reason has been entirely cut off from their soul, since they are still capable of thought.
Just as falling ill does not mean that health has been entirely cut off; a complete absence of health would mean death.
When we call water cold, its temperature may have fallen from five or six degrees to zero, and even toward absolute zero. Yet though we call it cold, it still contains warmth!