In Shia sources such as al-Kafi, Man La Yahduruhu al-Faqih, and Tahdhib al-Ahkam, there are reports about the Prophet’s inadvertence. How should we understand them? I have read the views of many eminent scholars who do not reject these reports. Could we say they were related as an act of taqiyya, to curb the exaggerations of those who went to extremes? Thank you.
Are the Reports of the Prophet’s Inadvertence Authentic?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The Qur’an and the Prophet’s truthfulness rule out the possibility of a verbal lapse on his part. Nor do the Infallibles (peace be upon them) make mistakes in practice; anyone liable to inadvertence would not be worthy of obedience. The Verse of Purification also declares their blessed souls free of every impurity, leaving no place for forgetfulness in their exalted station.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe clearest kind of lapse is a slip of the tongue, and the Noble Qur’an and its truthful witness declare the beloved and noble Messenger free of it!
النجم : 3 و ما ینطق عن الهوى
“He does not speak out of his own desire.”
النجم : 4 إن هو إلا وحی یوحى
“What he says is nothing but revelation revealed to him.”
In practical matters, too, the revered ones act by God’s command, and no error comes from them!
الفتح : 10 إن الذین یبایعونک إنما یبایعون الله ید الله فوق أیدیهم فمن نکث فإنما ینکث على نفسه و من أوفى بما عاهد علیه الله فسیؤتیه أجرا عظیما
“Those who pledge allegiance to you are in truth pledging allegiance to God. The hand of God is above their hands. So whoever breaks his pledge breaks it only to his own detriment; but whoever fulfils the covenant he has made with God will be granted a great reward.”
Anyone who is liable to lapse would not be worthy of obedience, since an unintended lapse could open the way to sin. Yet the Creator has declared obedience to them to be identical with obedience to Himself!
النساء : 59 یا أیها الذین آمنوا أطیعوا الله و أطیعوا الرسول و أولی الأمر منکم فإن تنازعتم فی شیء فردوه إلى الله و الرسول إن کنتم تؤمنون بالله و الیوم الآخر ذلک خیر و أحسن تأویلا
“O you who believe, obey God, obey the Messenger, and those vested with authority among you. If you disagree about anything, refer it to God and the Messenger, if you believe in God and the Last Day. That is better for you, and better in its outcome.”
The most beautiful proof is the Verse of Purification, which declares the revered ones’ blessed souls free from every impurity—let alone the slightest trace of lapse, which has no place in their noble stature!
إنما یرید الله لیذهب عنکم الرجس أهل البیت و یطهرکم تطهیرا
Let us not forget that the revered ones are the very reality of God’s Most Beautiful Names! To accuse them of lapsing is an allegation—even if it comes from Shaykh al-Saduq. This does not amount to ghuluw, for the Creator’s will concerning them has been fulfilled!