Greetings, and thank you for your efforts.
In light of the hadiths above, could you please explain whether all foods affect our behaviour?
الإمام الصادق «ع»: اللحم ینبت اللحم، و من ترک اللحم أربعین صباحا ساء خلقه. )
.« بحار» 66/ 66؛ from the book « المحاسن».
Imam al-Sadiq (peace be upon him) said: “Meat helps the body grow, and anyone who gives up eating meat for forty days will become bad-tempered.”
النبی «ص»- فیما رواه الإمام الصادق: علیکم باللحم، فإن اللحم ینمی اللحم. و من مضى به أربعون صباحا لم یأکل اللحم ساء خلقه. و من ساء خلقه فأطعموه اللحم ...
.« وسائل» 17/ 26- 27.
The Prophet (peace be upon him), as narrated by Imam al-Sadiq (peace be upon him), said: “You should eat meat, for meat helps the body grow. Anyone who goes forty days without eating meat will become bad-tempered. If someone becomes bad-tempered, feed them meat...”
Do All Foods Affect Our Behaviour?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
According to hadith, abstaining from meat for a prolonged period can lead to irritability. This can be understood in two ways: if someone is able to eat meat, which the body needs, but chooses not to, their resulting bad temper is blameworthy. But if they become morally listless because they are unable to eat meat, the goodness of their character remains intact.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe human being is a magnificent realm, whose incomparable Creator has provided everything this vast realm needs. A person’s appetite is, in fact, the response of the human cognitive system to the body’s demand for a particular need. So long as the body remains connected to the central command of the intellect and its forces, all the signals arising from within will be accompanied by appropriate responses, discoveries and sound processing. Even in recognizing pain and determining how to treat it and which medicine will cure the illness, the body will be guided by inner promptings and inspirations.
When a person follows the guidance of the intellect, they will be led aright: their need will be reliably identified and beautifully met. But when they cease to follow the intellect, the body will begin to deteriorate and the illness will worsen.
The hadith mentioned above points to a particular connection between prolonged abstention from meat and bad character. This matter can be understood in two ways.
If a person follows the guidance of the intellect, and a signal to meet a need comes from that source, then the person correctly recognizes the need—to eat meat—but disregards it, thereby transgressing against the intellect and committing an error. In this case, the person’s bad temper is blameworthy. But if they are unable to meet their need, they suffer not from bad character but from a moral affliction. They will not be able to express their good character fully, but inwardly their good nature will remain intact. (الامام الصادق علیه السلام یعلم)