In this hadith, the Shia are described as people who have little contact with others and spend much of their time in seclusion. How can this be reconciled with the example of the Prophet (PBUH)? He was a mercy to all the worlds; he even visited his enemies and comforted them, called on them when they were ill, and so on. He was a deeply social and compassionate person who drew everyone to him through love and kindness. How, then, can the Shia and his followers live apart from people and in seclusion?
How can the Shia’s seclusion be reconciled with the Prophet’s (PBUH) social example?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The seclusion of the Shia means keeping away from worldly people, not from people of faith. Believers engage with society to encourage what is right and forbid what is wrong, but they do not take part in its heedlessness. Their engagement with society is meant to guide others, not to share in sin or worldly preoccupations.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center**True believers are always together**
If we look closely at the different aspects of this narration, we see that its reference to seclusion means that believers keep their distance from worldly people, not from people of faith. Believers share a common way of life. Even if they seek solitude, they will meet one another in their retreats and share a special bond. The narration is pointing to the fact that believers are not attached to this world.
Believers never withdraw from society when it comes to offering counsel, exhortation and guidance, or enjoining what is right and forbidding what is wrong. They never abandon their connection with people in carrying out the duty of enjoining right and so on. But they do not, under any circumstances, share in people’s heedlessness!
Believers do not make the company of those who follow falsehood their own, but they do not neglect to guide them. Nor do they give up maintaining ties with their relatives and loved ones; they make this an essential part of their lives.
الفرقان : 28 یا ویلتى لیتنی لم أتخذ فلانا خلیلا
“Woe is me! If only I had not taken so-and-so—that misguided person—as a friend!”
الزخرف : 38 حتى إذا جاءنا قال یا لیت بینی و بینک بعد المشرقین فبئس القرین
“When he comes before Us, he will say, ‘If only the distance between me and you were as far as that between east and west! What a wretched companion you were!’”
How beautifully the Mawla has described the people of faith and God-consciousness!
... إن کان فی الغافلین کتب فی الذاکرین و إن کان فی الذاکرین لم یکتب من الغافلین ...
نهج البلاغه (للصبحی صالح)، ص: 306
“When they are among the heedless, they are counted among those who remember God”—their names are recorded among those who remember Him; even among the heedless, they never forget God. “And when they are among those who remember God, they are not counted among the heedless”—among those who remember Him, they add to the vitality of God’s remembrance and never obstruct it or become a cause of anyone’s heedlessness.
In short, true believers understand their responsibilities toward society and fulfil them, but they never allow themselves to be swept up in society’s undesirable ways.