Peace be upon you. In light of this verse from Surah Yusuf, I wonder how God will forgive grave sins that violate the rights of others. What does this forgiveness mean, and in what ways will it be granted?
قال لا تثریب علیکم الیوم یغفر الله لکم وهو أرحم الراحمین
(Joseph) said, “No reproach shall be upon you today. May God forgive you; He is the Most Merciful of those who show mercy.” (92)
(Given that the sin of Joseph’s brothers involved both wronging their brother and wronging their father, both of which violate the rights of others.)
How Does God Forgive Sins That Violate the Rights of Others?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The rights of others are also rights owed to God. When God forgives, He does not call anyone to account; rather, He makes good the rights that were violated in a fitting way. The forgiveness shown by Joseph and Jacob in Surah Yusuf is an example of this.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe rights of people cannot take precedence over the rights of God. In fact, the rights of people are themselves connected to the rights of God, since they are owed by human beings, who are His creation. The Creator has a claim upon His creatures by virtue of all the blessings He bestows on them; and, because each creature has rights that other creatures must observe, He also holds all His creation accountable for respecting those rights. Thus, the rights of people ultimately return to the rights of God.
When the Creator forgives, no creature can call Him to account. Whatever He wills is right, and nothing can stand in the way of His will. If the Creator forgives one of His servants who is indebted to other servants, this certainly does not mean that the wronged servant’s rights have been disregarded: the Creator will make fitting recompense for every loss.
Yet the seeking of forgiveness for his sons by Jacob عليه السلام, as mentioned in the verse, shows that he had forgiven them and was also asking the Creator to forgive them. Joseph عليه السلام, too, graciously and magnanimously let his brothers’ wrongdoing go.