How would you critique Hadiths 8 and 9 in Chapter 11 of the Book of Divine Unity, which hold that the attributes’ being additional to the Essence entails shirk and anthropomorphism?
How should Hadiths 8 and 9 in Chapter 11 of the Book of Divine Unity, on the divine attributes, be critiqued?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Denying attributes as distinct from God’s Essence does not mean denying perfection or power; rather, it affirms a transcendence beyond perfection. The attributes of created beings are limited, while God’s Essence is beyond our limited descriptions. The attributes are not identical with the Essence, and the Essence cannot be described through our limited framework. Any description offered by human beings is understood through the framework of their created nature, which the Creator transcends.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterIt should be understood that denying attributes of the Essence, as expressed in «و کمال الإخلاص له نفی الصفات عنه», does not mean denying the Essence’s perfection, power or knowledge. Rather, it affirms that His perfection, power and knowledge transcend all limits!
We must bear in mind that the Real Essence is free of the attributes of created beings. Every description formed by human beings is understood and acquired through the faculties with which they were created; the Creator is far above and beyond these, beyond description and expression.
Take care: attributes are known through descriptions, and an attribute without a description has no meaning. His Essence cannot be described! If we suppose His attribute to be identical with His Essence, we have undertaken to describe the Essence itself!
The human apparatus of creation is limited, as are its faculties of understanding and perception. Its reasoning, reflection, understanding and powers of description are also limited, for what is limited in its capacity will produce only what is limited. Thus every description of God formed through this limited apparatus will itself be limited, while His Essence is exalted above such descriptions. We give our own descriptions the name “attributes,” but He has no need of anything or of any attribute!
عن أبان بن عثمان الأحمر قال: قلت للصادق جعفر بن محمد ع أخبرنی عن الله تبارک و تعالى لم یزل سمیعا بصیرا علیما قادرا قال نعم فقلت له إن رجلا ینتحل موالاتکم أهل البیت یقول إن الله تبارک و تعالى لم یزل سمیعا بسمع و بصیرا ببصر و علیما بعلم و قادرا بقدره فغضب ع ثم قال من قال ذلک و دان به فهو مشرک و لیس من ولایتنا على شیء إن الله تبارک و تعالى ذات علامه سمیعه بصیره قادره.
عن أبی جعفر ع أنه قال: من صفه القدیم أنه واحد أحد صمد أحدی المعنى و لیس بمعان کثیره مختلفه قال قلت جعلت فداک یزعم قوم من أهل العراق أنه یسمع بغیر الذی یبصر و یبصر بغیر الذی یسمع قال فقال کذبوا و ألحدوا و شبهوا تعالى الله عن ذلک إنه سمیع بصیر یسمع بما یبصر و یبصر بما یسمع قال قلت یزعمون أنه بصیر على ما یعقلونه قال فقال تعالى الله إنما یعقل ما کان بصفه المخلوقین و لیس الله کذلک
التوحید (للصدوق)، ص: 144