Is the Ashʿarite view that the attributes are distinct from the divine Essence a sound interpretation?
Is the Ashʿarite View That the Divine Attributes Are Distinct from God’s Essence Correct?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The Ashʿarites have no coherent account of the divine attributes and are analytically confused. In broad terms, they speak only of the attributes as additional to the Essence. In a more detailed analysis, they distinguish between the mental and the external, and conclude that the attributes are neither identical with the Essence nor other than it.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe Ashʿarites do not hold a coherent position on the divine names and attributes; their discussions display a distinctive confusion and analytical disorder.
**Some Ashʿarite views**
The Ashʿarite position on the attributes can be divided into two stages: an outline stage and a more detailed stage. At the outline stage, they speak only of the attributes being additional to the Essence, without clarifying whether this addition is real or intellectual—in other words, whether it exists in the mind or in external reality. At the more detailed stage, however, the Ashʿarites distinguish between mind and reality, and between concept and referent. They conclude that “in mental apprehension and conceptual analysis, the Essence and the attributes are two things,” and that the attributes are additional to, and other than, the Essence. Yet in objective apprehension and in reality, “we are faced with a single reality—that is, the Essence of God.” From this perspective, the attributes are not other than the Essence. The Ashʿarites therefore ultimately conclude that “God’s attributes are neither identical with His Essence nor other than His Essence,” or that “in one respect they are identical with His Essence, and in another respect they are other than His Essence” (Dadbeh, “Ashʿarites,” vol. 8, p. 739; see also Amoli, جامع الاسرار, pp. 138–39, 644).