One of the strangest verses in the Noble Quran is the verse about the ambiguous passages. When people argue over it, they are in fact acting contrary to the commands and prohibitions it contains.
Do you consider my humble understanding and interpretation of the following verse concerning the Quran’s clear and ambiguous passages to be correct? In light of the explanation I will offer below, I think this verse describes how those firmly grounded in knowledge—the Prophet and his Household, peace be upon them—receive knowledge from God. That is, they refrain from probing matters that are not obligatory (see the hadith at the end of this question), and affirm the Quran as a whole in general terms. Then God, Exalted is He, makes them aware of the interpretation of the ambiguous passages because they acknowledge their ignorance.
آلعمران : 7 هو الذی أنزل علیک الکتاب منه آیات محکمات هن أم الکتاب و أخر متشابهات فأما الذین فی قلوبهم زیغ فیتبعون ما تشابه منه ابتغاء الفتنه و ابتغاء تأویله و ما یعلم تأویله إلا الله و الراسخون فی العلم یقولون آمنا به کل من عند ربنا و ما یذکر إلا أولوا الألباب
The following points are all based on the verse above and on narrations. I will cite one such narration below. Only the final synthesis (points 7 and 8) is my own, and I hope you will critique it.
1. The foremost among those firmly grounded in knowledge are the Prophet and his Household, peace be upon them. (A hadith in Usul al-Kafi)
2. Those firmly grounded in knowledge do not seek to stir up discord or interpret the ambiguous verses. (The verse above)
3. They refrain from probing matters that God has not made obligatory for them, as indicated by the hadith from al-Tawhid by Shaykh al-Saduq, p. 56, which I will cite below.
4. It is precisely because they refrain from such probing that God, Exalted is He, teaches the interpretation of the verses to the Prophet and his Household, peace be upon them.
5. But those who seek to divide Muslims—including Sunnis and Shi‘is—interpret the ambiguous verses in order to stir up discord. (The verse above)
6. Only God knows the interpretation of the ambiguous passages, and He teaches it to those who acknowledge their ignorance about them by saying, « آمنا به کل من عند ربنا ». Thus, through their faith and submission in the face of what they do not know about the Quran, they too come to know the interpretation of the verses. (The verse and hadith below)
7. The conclusion, and the most important point: In light of this explanation, it is my personal view that this verse describes how those firmly grounded in knowledge—the Household of the Prophet—receive knowledge from God, Exalted is He! That is, because the Ahl al-Bayt, peace be upon them, acknowledge their ignorance in the face of the Quran’s ambiguous passages, God teaches them their interpretation and praises them as “firmly grounded in knowledge” (penetrating deeply into knowledge). No verse remains ambiguous to them: they know its interpretation alongside God.
8. A secondary point: This account also brings to light the problem with the disciplines sometimes called “pure rationalism” in discussions of reason. Those who are said to practise pure rationalism accuse their opponents of being opposed to reason! Yet on this account, God, Exalted is He, praises those firmly grounded in knowledge precisely because they refrain from probing matters that He has not made obligatory for them. In this way they become firmly grounded in knowledge (penetrate deeply into it) and come to know its interpretations! For true knowledge is light, and to attain that light one must submit wholly to the Lord. Whoever has complete, general faith in the whole Quran—« آمنا به کل من عند ربنا »—will have their knowledge made manifest by God. This is discussed at length in the articles on submission. Thaqalayn Channel—Questions of Divine Unity.
A hadith from the Commander of the Faithful, Ali ibn Abi Talib, peace be upon them:
“And know that those firmly grounded in knowledge
are those whom God has spared from the terrifying fall into dead-end paths beyond the realms of the unseen (?);
they therefore held fast to affirming all that they did not know how to interpret among the veiled matters of the unseen,
and said: آمنا به کل من عند ربنا (We believe in it; all of it is from our Lord);
so God, Mighty and Glorious, praised their acknowledgment of their inability to reach what they have no knowledge of;
and He called their ‘refraining’ from pursuing what they had not been charged to seek ‘being firmly grounded (in knowledge)’!
So be content with this;
and do not measure the greatness of God, Glorified is He, by the limits of your own intellect, lest you become one of the perishing.”
(Al-Tawhid, Shaykh al-Saduq, p. 56)