In light of the following two hadiths, which classification of the heart is more accurate? Or is there no contradiction in accepting both classifications?
1- «إن القلوب أربعه: قلب فیه نفاق و إیمان، و قلب منکوس، و قلب مطبوع، و قلب أزهر أجرد»- فقلت: ما الأزهر؟ قال: «فیه کهیئه السراج- فأما المطبوع، فقلب المنافق، و أما الأزهر، فقلب المؤمن؛ إن أعطاه شکر، و إن ابتلاه صبر؛ و أما المنکوس، فقلب المشرک».
2- عن أبی جعفر علیه السلام، قال: «القلوب ثلاثه: قلب منکوس لایعی شیئا من الخیر، و هو قلب الکافر؛ و قلب فیه نکته سوداء، فالخیر و الشر فیه یعتلجان، فأیهما کانت منه غلب علیه؛ و قلب مفتوح، فیه مصابیح تزهر، و لایطفأ نوره إلى یوم القیامه، و هو قلب المؤمن».
Which Classification of the Heart in the Hadiths Is More Accurate?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Both classifications of the heart mentioned in the hadiths are sound. The first hadith, which identifies four kinds of heart—a heart containing both hypocrisy and faith, an inverted heart, a sealed heart, and a radiant heart—seems more comprehensive, since it includes the sealed heart, which is no longer open to guidance. The radiant heart is the heart of a believer who gives thanks for blessings and remains patient in hardship.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterBoth are more accurate! In fact, the first hadith mentions a sealed heart, which is absent from the second. The first hadith is more complete: once a heart has been sealed, it can no longer be guided. The ultimate loser is the one who forfeits the chance to serve God!