یقوم ادخلوا الارض المقدسه التی کتب الله لکم..... (Al-Ma'idah 5:21)
Professor, according to this ruling, can Jews claim that the land of Palestine belongs to them—or at least that it does not belong to Muslims? How can we respond to someone making this claim?
Can Jews Claim Ownership of Palestine on the Basis of Verse 21 of Surah al-Ma’idah?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The permission to enter the Holy Land mentioned in verse 21 of Surah al-Ma'idah does not establish any right of ownership for the Children of Israel. Rather, it was an act of divine grace that granted them permission to enter the land. As the subsequent verses make clear, they brazenly disobeyed the command of the Almighty, and ultimately incurred divine punishment after Moses (peace be upon him) disavowed them.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Centerالمائده : 21 یا قوم ادخلوا الأرض المقدسه التی کتب الله لکم و لا ترتدوا على أدبارکم فتنقلبوا خاسرین
“O my people! Enter the holy land that God has decreed for you, and do not turn back, or you will be losers.”
Permission to enter the holy land did not establish any right of ownership for them. They had merely received an act of divine grace and favor: permission to enter that land.
Even if this were somehow correct—which is impossible—the verses that follow show that they brazenly disobeyed the command of the Most High and ultimately incurred divine punishment after Moses علیه السلام disavowed them.
یاقوم ادخلوا الأرض المقدسه التى کتب الله لکم و لا ترتدوا على أدبارکم فتنقلبوا خسرین(21)
قالوا یاموسى إن فیها قوما جبارین و إنا لن ندخلها حتى یخرجوا منها فإن یخرجوا منها فإنا داخلون(22)
قال رجلان من الذین یخافون أنعم الله علیهما ادخلوا علیهم الباب فإذا دخلتموه فإنکم غلبون و على الله فتوکلوا إن کنتم مؤمنین(23)
قالوا یموسى إنا لن ندخلها أبدا ما داموا فیها
فاذهب أنت و ربک فقتلا إنا هاهنا قعدون(24)
قال رب إنى لا أملک إلا نفسى و أخى فافرق بیننا و بین القوم الفسقین(25)
قال فإنها محرمه علیهم أربعين سنه یتیهون فى الأرض فلا تأس على القوم الفاسقین(26)
“O my people! Enter the holy land that God has decreed for you, and do not turn back, or you will be losers.” (21)
They said, “O Moses! There is a powerful and oppressive people in that land. We will never enter it until they leave. If they leave, then we will enter.” (22)
Two men who feared God, and whom He had blessed, said, “Enter the city by its gate. Once you have entered it, you will surely prevail. Put your trust in God, if you are believers.” (23)
They said, “O Moses! We will never enter it while they remain there. So go, you and your Lord, and fight them. We will stay right here.” (24)
He said, “My Lord, I have authority over no one but myself and my brother. So separate us from this sinful people.” (25)
He said, “Then it shall be forbidden to them for forty years. They will wander the earth, so do not grieve over this sinful people.” (26)
Permission to enter the holy land does not amount to a deed of ownership over it, any more than permission to perform Hajj and visit the holy places, or to enter the Masjid al-Haram, makes anyone the owner of Mecca.