The Qur’an should be interpreted through narrations so that we can avoid interpreting it according to personal opinion. 2—Authentic and inauthentic narrations should be distinguished on the basis of the Qur’an. Doesn’t this lead to circular reasoning? In other words, doesn’t understanding the Qur’an depend on hadith, while understanding hadith depends on the Qur’an? Or are the premises above mistaken?
#Answer 881
Interpretation becomes necessary when we seek to uncover what is hidden in God’s verses, or when, like a mining engineer, we strive to extract the Qur’an’s profound and concealed teachings. The Qur’an’s clear verses state the truths plainly and can serve as a basis for distinguishing what is right from what is wrong. But to reach the allusions, subtleties, and deeper truths within those very verses, we certainly need a vast source of revealed knowledge: the narrations of the Infallible Imams عليهم السلام.
النساء : 174 یا أیها الناس قد جاءکم برهان من ربکم و أنزلنا إلیکم نورا مبینا
“O people, a clear proof has come to you from your Lord, and We have sent down to you a manifest light.”
As for the claim that “the authenticity of narrations must be measured against the Qur’an,” the answer is already contained in the wording of the question. Narrations, properly speaking—that is, reports whose transmission from the Infallible Imams has been established and whose authenticity we are certain of—do not need to be examined for authenticity. Authentic narrations accompany the Qur’an and interpret it. What we assess for authenticity is whether fabricated statements falsely attributed to the Infallible Imams were in fact transmitted from them. There is no circularity here, because once we have established that a narration is authentic, there is no need to test whether it accords with the verses.
For the Qur’an is God’s speech, conveyed by the Messenger and the awliya’ of God صلوات الله علیهم, and we accept it.