In Quran 2:28, what stage in the emergence of humankind does the phrase “كُنتُمْ أَمْوَاتًا” refer to? In which realm was the human being dead before being brought to life? What does being “dead” mean here?
Quran 2:28: What Does “كُنتُمْ أَمْوَاتًا” Mean?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
In Quran 2:28, “كُنتُمْ أَمْوَاتًا” refers to the absence of worldly life. Human beings were as though dead while in their fathers’ loins; before they were created, however, they cannot be described as dead. The verse points to the different stages of human life and death, including life in the loins, death in this world, life in the grave, and life at the Resurrection.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center“Dead” here means lacking the life of this world: human beings, while in their fathers’ loins, were regarded as dead. It should be noted that nonexistence is not counted as death; death refers to the state after life, when life has ended. We may suppose that human beings had a kind of life before they came to rest in their fathers’ loins, and that they passed from that stage into those loins. A person is not called dead before being created.
قال الإمام ع قال رسول الله ص لکفار قریش و الیهود:
کیف تکفرون بالله الذی دلکم على طرق الهدى، و جنبکم أن أطعتموه سبل «2» الردى.
و کنتم أمواتا
فی أصلاب آبائکم و أرحام أمهاتکم.
فأحیاکم أخرجکم أحیاء ثم یمیتکم فی هذه الدنیا و یقبرکم.
ثم یحییکم فی القبور، و ینعم فیها المؤمنین بنبوه محمد ص و ولایه علی ع، و یعذب فیها الکافرین بهما.
ثم إلیه ترجعون فی الآخره- بأن تموتوا فی القبور بعد، ثم تحیوا «3» للبعث یوم القیامه، ترجعون إلى ما وعدکم من الثواب على الطاعات- إن کنتم فاعلیها، و من العقاب على المعاصی إن کنتم مقارفیها «4».
[حدیث نعيم القبر و عذابه، و رؤيه المحتضر للأئمه ع
فقیل له: یا ابن رسول الله «5» ففی القبر نعیم، و عذاب
التفسیر المنسوب إلى الإمام الحسن العسکری علیه السلام، ص: 210