Please explain the difference between reflection and reasoning, and ta’wil and interpreting the Quran based on personal opinion.
What Is the Difference Between Reflection and Reasoning, and Ta’wil and Personal Interpretation of the Quran?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Reflection and reasoning mean using the light of the intellect to discover the truth: reflection is like making use of light, while reasoning is like becoming light itself. Interpreting the Quran based on personal opinion, by contrast, means forming hypotheses without the guidance of the intellect and the Prophet’s family. It is a transgression against the sanctity of the Quran.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterReflection means, under the guidance of reason, paying close attention in order to discover the truth. In other words, it means opening the gates of the heart to the discovery of truth; or, to put it another way, opening the heart’s eye fully to the truth. More simply, it means turning the heart’s light upon things and witnessing the beauty of the Real and the realities themselves!
Rational discernment means, equipped with all the virtues of noble character and under the guidance of reason, directing particular and sustained attention toward realities. The difference between reflection and rational discernment is like the difference between benefiting from a ray of light and becoming the light itself—or being inseparable from it. In reflection, a person benefits from the light; in rational discernment, a person becomes like the light!
From the hadith about the hosts of reason and ignorance, we know that reflection is one of reason’s soldiers!
Exegesis and interpretation based on personal opinion mean devising theories without drawing on light and illumination. We know that only the perspective of the pure and infallible Household of the Prophet commands a view of the Qur’an’s sublime beauty; their vantage point must be our own. Otherwise, any claim to exegesis or interpretation is an act of presumption against a sanctuary one has no access to—a hand too short to reach, yet claiming to do the work of God’s hand!