In light of the following verse, what is disputation? What kinds of discussion does it include, and to what extent? Where are its limits? People invoke this verse in discussions and urge those who disagree not to engage in disputation. Please explain.
فإن حاجوک فقل أسلمت وجهی لله ومن اتبعن وقل للذین أوتوا الکتاب والأمیین أأسلمتم فإن أسلموا فقد اهتدوا وإن تولوا فإنما علیک البلاغ والله بصیر بالعباد ﴿20﴾ If they contend with you, (do not argue with them, but) say: “I and those who follow me have submitted to God (and His command).” And say to those who were given the Book (the Jews and Christians) and to the unlettered (the polytheists): “Have you too submitted?” If they submit (to the command and logic of the truth), they will be guided; but if they turn away, (do not be concerned, for) your only duty is to deliver the message. And God sees His servants and all that they do and believe. (20)
In light of Āl ʿImrān 3:20, what is disputation, and what subjects does it encompass?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
In Āl ʿImrān 3:20, mujādala means presenting proofs and arguments in discussion. When both sides are people of faith and knowledge, their arguments should remain within the bounds of knowledge. If they lack a sound understanding of the subject or cannot offer scholarly evidence, they should not enter into debate. If the other party is ignorant and obstinate, one should skillfully use appropriate techniques to counter their uninformed argument.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe noble verse refers to disputation: that is, presenting proofs and evidence in discussion. If both sides are people of faith and knowledge, their arguments must remain within the bounds of knowledge. If they lack sound knowledge of the subject or cannot offer scholarly evidence, they should not enter into discussion, debate or disputation.
Āl ʿImrān: 66
ها أنتم هؤلاء حاججتم فیما لکم به علم فلم تحاجون فیما لیس لکم به علم و الله یعلم و أنتم لا تعلمون
“Here you are, arguing about what you know. Why, then, argue about what you do not know? God knows, and you do not know.”
There is no point in disputing matters that are plain and self-evident!
Al-Baqarah: 139
قل أ تحاجوننا فی الله و هو ربنا و ربکم و لنا أعمالنا و لکم أعمالکم و نحن له مخلصون
“Say: ‘Would you argue with us about God, when He is our Lord and your Lord? Our deeds belong to us, and your deeds belong to you, and we are devoted to Him alone.’”
When the other party is ignorant and obstinate, one must deftly apply particular techniques to counter their uninformed arguments. The disputations of Abraham and Muhammad (ص) are examples of this.
Al-Baqarah: 258
أ لم تر إلى الذی حاج إبراهیم فی ربه أن آتاه الله الملک إذ قال إبراهیم ربی الذی یحیی و یمیت قال أنا أحیی و أمیت قال إبراهیم فإن الله یأتی بالشمس من المشرق فأت بها من المغرب فبهت الذی کفر و الله لا یهدی القوم الظالمین
“Have you not heard of the one [Nimrod] who argued with Abraham about his Lord, because God had granted him kingship?” When Abraham said, “My Lord is the One who gives life and causes death,” he replied, “I too give life and cause death.” (To make his claim seem true and confuse the people, he ordered two prisoners to be brought before him, then commanded that one be set free and the other put to death.) Abraham said, “God brings the sun from the east, so bring it from the west, if you are truthful.” The disbeliever was struck dumb, and God does not guide the wrongdoing people.
Āl ʿImrān: 61
فمن حاجک فیه من بعد ما جاءک من العلم فقل تعالوا ندع أبناءنا و أبناءکم و نساءنا و نساءکم و أنفسنا و أنفسکم ثم نبتهل فنجعل لعنت الله على الکاذبین
“If anyone disputes with you about him [Jesus Christ, peace be upon him] after the knowledge that has come to you, say: ‘Come, let us call our sons and your sons, our women and your women, and ourselves and yourselves—those who are as close to us as our own lives—then let us pray earnestly, calling down God’s curse upon the liars.’” In this event, the Prophet brought al-Hasan and al-Husayn as his sons, Fatimah as his women, and ʿAli as himself to the mutual imprecation; the disbelievers then submitted.
A sound grounding in knowledge and wisdom, together with the ability to apply them rationally and intelligently, is essential to every disputation.